taariikhda waqoyga somaliyeed
      A' 
TP\ 
UNDER THE FLAG 
and Somali Coast Stories 
Photo by] 
[Elliott & Fry 
LAXGTOX PRENDERGAST WALSH, C.I.E. 
[Frontispiece 
UNDER THE FLAG 
and Somali Coast Stories 
By 
LANGTON PRENDERGAST WALSH, 
C.I.E. 
WITH FRONTISPIECE 
London : 
ANDREW MELROSE, LTD. 
PATERNOSTER HOUSE, ..4 
MADE AND PRINTED IN 
GREAT BRITAIN, FOR 
ANDREW MELROSE, LTD., 
AT THE ANCHOR PRESS, 
: : TIPTREF, ESSEX : : 
CONTENTS 
PART I 
CHAPTER PAWI 
I. MY BIRTHDAY FEBRUARY 29TH - - II 
II. BARODA ------- 12 
III. "A STRONG MAN ARMED" - - - 19 
IV. BOYHOOD DAYS - - - - - -*5 
V. ODSEY GRANGE AND COWLEY - - '33 
VI. WAR CLOUDS ------ 42 
VII. BOMBAY -------49 
VIII. THE MUTINY INDIAN CIVIL SERVANTS - - 65 
IX. SUEZ AND EGYPT ----- gl 
X. THE MARINE POSTAL SERVICE 90 
XI. ADVENTURES IN SUEZ - - - - - IO2 
XII. GENERAL ULYSSES GRANT, EX-PRESIDENT U.S.A. IO8 
XIII. INDIA AS A MARRIAGE MARKET - - -113 
XIV. A MEETING WITH SIR RICHARD BURTON - I2O 
XV. UNAUTHORIZED ADVENTURES - - - 136 
XVI. I MEET GENERAL GORDON - - ^144 
xvii. A SURVIVOR'S TALE OF GORDON'S DEATH - 154 
XVIII. ARMS AND MEN - - - - 157 
XIX. THE CAMPAIGN OFl882 - - - -l6o 
XX. ISMAILIA - - - - - - i6y 
XXI. THE AMMUNITION CASES AND TEL-EL-KEBIR - 175 
XXII. COLONEL VALENTINE BAKER - TV - 1 82 
XXIII. LONDON INDIA OFFICE AND WAR OFFICE - 193 
Til 
1179134 ' 
via 
CHAPTER PAGE 
I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF MY EMPLOYMENT IN 
SOMALILAND - '-, \> - - 199 
II. THE FRENCH SCORE THE FIRST TRICK - - 204 
III. ADMINISTRATION OF THE SOMALI COAST, 
1883-1885 - -220 
IV. BERBERA - - - - 233 
V. ENCOUNTERS WITH NEIGHBOURING TRIBES - 243 
VI. THE CAPTURE OF A PRINCESS - - - 2 54 
VII. SOME RELIGIOUS, MEDICAL, AND FISCAL ASPECTS 265 
VIII. PUNITIVE EXPEDITION AGAINST THE JIBRIL 
ABUKER CLANS, 1 8 88 
IX. THE OLD AND NEW REGIME IN SOMALILAND - 
X. THE JAMES EXPEDITION, 1884 
XI. SHIPPING CAMELS UNDER DIFFICULTIES, AND 
A TRICK AGAINST THE FRENCH - - 297 
XII. VISITORS TO THE BERBERA RESIDENCY - - 306 
XIII. 2EILA - - - - - - -319 
XIV. COMBATING FRENCH INFLUENCE AT ZEILA - 324 
XV. ALARUMS AND EXCURSIONS THE SAGALLO 
INCIDENT - - - "- '. '- 329 
XVI. MY UNPOPULARITY WITH THE FRENCH AND 
WITH THE SLAVE-TRADERS ^WELL-SINKING 
NEAR ZEILA - '?* - cW? - -V- 
XVII. THE BAITING OF THE BLACK AYSA UGHAZ 
XVIII. I RETURN ONCE MORE TO ZEILA AND RECEIVE 
AN OFFICIAL DEPUTATION 360 
XIX. SOMALI CHARACTERISTICS AND CONDITIONS - 370 
XX. I MEET THE RT. HON. SIR HENRY MORTIMER 
DURAND, AND IN 1892 LEAVE ZEILA - - 376 
APPENDIX - - - - ~3 8 3 
PART I 
CHAPTER I 
MY BIRTHDAY FEBRUARY 29TH 
I WAS born on the 29th of February, 1856, in the British 
cantonment at Baroda, the capital of the Gaekwar's 
territory in Gujarat, Bombay Presidency. 
The Reverend James Henry Hughes, M.A., Chaplain 
of the Church of England at Surat, with pastoral charge 
of Broach and Baroda, baptized me in St. James's Church, 
Baroda, on the loth of March. I was christened Langton 
Prendergast, and registered as the son of Thomas Prender- 
gast Boles Walsh, ensign of the ist Grenadier Regiment 
of the Bombay Army. My mother was Euphemia Frances 
Elizabeth, only child by his first marriage of the Reverend 
William Spencer Walsh, D.D., T.C.D., of Knockboyne, 
Navan, Co. Meath, Vicar of Asseyalvoin, Meath, and later 
Rector of Clonard, Co. Meath, Ireland. 
Shortly after my birth, my father's sword-orderly, 
Private Raghoo, in accordance with the customary treat- 
ment of male children of noble descent, employed an 
astrologer to prepare my horoscope. And therein he 
records that my birth took place in the "Shoo", or bright 
half of the lunar month. Some forty years later this 
document was produced by this old Grenadier when he 
came to see me at the Residency, Sawant-Wadi. I have no 
fault to find with its predictions, many of which have been 
fulfilled to my great advantage and welfare. 
CHAPTER II 
BARODA 
AT the time of my birth in 1856, Gunpatrao Gaekwar was 
the ruler of Baroda. He died on the 1 9th of November, 1856, 
and was succeeded by Khanderao Gaekwar. Major C. 
Davidson was the Acting Political Resident at Baroda in 
1856 and 1857. Lt.-Colonel W. C. Stather commanded 
the ist Bombay Grenadier Regiment, and was also the 
senior officer in charge of the troops in garrison at Baroda. 
My father, Thomas Prendergast Boles Walsh, had 
joined the Grenadiers in March 1853. He was not the 
first of our kinsmen to be connected with that city and 
State, as his uncle, Guy Lenox Prendergast, of the Bombay 
Civil Service, had been there a few years earlier as the 
British Resident. At a later date the latter became a 
Member of Council, Bombay, and, after retirement from 
India, was an M.P. for Lymington. He died in 1 845 , and 
was buried at the main entrance of the church at Tunbridge 
Wells. In 1856 my father was still an ensign of the 
Grenadiers at Baroda. 
Sir Henry Creswicke Rawlinson, K.C.B., in the early 
part of 1856 was a captain in the ist Grenadiers. His 
company was remarkable for the average height of its rank 
and file, 5 ft. 8J ins. being tall for Marathas, who are by 
race small of stature. Rawlinson had been away from the 
regiment for several years, during which period he had 
served in the Political and Diplomatic Services in Afghani- 
stan, and at the Court of the Shah of Persia. He retired 
from the Army in 1856, and in September 1858 became a 
Member of the Council of India and M.P. for Reigate. 
Later he was for many years a Member of the Council 
of the Secretary of State for India. He was made a 
baronet, and died in March 1895, leaving a son, who was 
created Baron Rawlinson as a reward for brilliant services 
BARODA 13 
in the Great War, and at his death in 1925 held the post of 
Commander-in-Chief in India. 
When Sir Henry Rawlinson decided to leave the 
Grenadiers in 1856, he wrote to his old friend and comrade 
Colonel Stather, asking him to select an officer for the 
command of his old company. Sir Henry required an 
officer who was likely to evince the same interest as himself 
in the domestic and financial affairs of the men of his 
company. In compliance with this request Colonel Stather 
posted Ensign Walsh to command the company, regimen- 
tally known as Rawlinson's. That appointment did not carry 
with it any rise in rank, nor did it accelerate promotion ; 
but it marked and recorded the Commanding Officer's 
appreciation of the efficient services already exhibited by 
that ensign, and at the same time the latter was thereby 
qualified to draw two full allowances, totalling fifty rupees 
monthly, in addition to the pay of his military rank. 
My father carried out Rawlinson's policy, namely 
that Rawlinson always exercised his influence with the 
judges of local courts, and with collectors and the heads 
of provinces, to impede the efforts of the village sowcars 
(moneylenders) to foreclose the mortgages on the hereditary 
farms (Buttons] of these Maratha soldiers. For the men 
were recruited from both slopes of the Sayadri range of 
mountains, in which districts Brahmins possessed con- 
siderable influence and had frequently attempted to seduce 
Maratha sepoys from their allegiance to the Sirkar. The 
Brahmins' object was the ousting of the British as the para- 
mount power, and a first step towards making the Nana 
Sahib of Bithur ruler at Poona, thus restoring Brahmin 
supremacy in the Deccan. Rawlinson thought that by 
protecting and assisting the Maratha fighting man, Brahmin 
wiles and intrigues could be frustrated and rendered futile. 
The absolute correctness of these views was fully 
proved by the loyalty and devotion to duty shown by the 
men of this famous Maratha regiment during the mutiny 
of the Native Army in 1857. The ist Bombay Grenadiers 
had no kind of sympathy with the mutinous sepoys of the 
Bengal Army, or with the few disloyal men in two or three 
Bombay regiments. 
i 4 UNDER THE FLAG 
About May 1856 a couple of bungalows adjoining 
the native town, but actually within the limits of the 
British cantonment, were burned by some rascals from 
Baroda city, who unfortunately got away before they 
could be caught by the military police. These scoundrels 
were arrested by the Gaekwari police, and severely dealt 
with by the magistrates of the Baroda State. The people 
of Baroda not only showed no sympathy with these in- 
cendiaries, but openly expressed their approval of the 
punishments meted out to them by the Baroda Criminal 
Court. 
My father and mother resided close to the site of these 
outrages, and Colonel Stather, as a precautionary measure, 
ordered my father to vacate his quarters and take a bungalow 
nearer the regimental lines. Colonel Stather also instructed 
my father to equip his company fully, and keep it in readiness 
for field service at twenty-four hours' notice, the time 
judged as necessary to collect transport. 
My mother declined to go to Europe, but went to stay 
with the Collector of Surat, Mr. George Inverarity, I.C.S., 
who hospitably sheltered European women and children 
from all parts of Gujarat. She held a facile pen, and wrote 
weekly, under the heading of "Gujarat Gossip", social news- 
letters for the Bombay journals, in which contributions 
she often set forth her personal views of Baroda and Kutch 
affairs, as she saw and heard them in the zenana and behind 
the purdah. 
My father took a great interest in the affairs and the 
administration of the Baroda State, and published a book 
entitled Goo^erat and the Country of the Gulcowar. The book 
attracted the attention of the Political Department, and he 
came to be regarded as an authority on Baroda and its 
territory. He was offered a political assistantship in that 
residency, which post he was desirous of filling, but only 
on the understanding that he would be permitted to rejoin 
his regiment whenever he wished to do so. The civil and 
military authorities would not grant the condition asked 
for by my father, although he had frequently notified them 
of his preference for regimental employment. Neverthe- 
less, he had constantly acted for short periods in several 
BARODA 15 
Civil offices. He often remarked to me that in early life 
he could easily have permanently joined a Civil department, 
but if he had done so it would have restricted and fettered 
his pen, and he had always intended to use both his pen 
and his sword during his career in India. 
My father was intimately acquainted with the Gaekwars 
of Baroda, their ministers, and the notables of Gujarat, 
up to the end of 1858. He was also on very confidential 
terms with Khan Bahadur Shahabuddin Kazi, then at 
Bhooj, but before and after a Minister of the Baroda 
Government. Through the aid and influence of this 
useful friend my father was able in his personal capacity 
to obtain valuable and reliable information upon various 
matters relating to Baroda, which he secretly and expedi- 
tiously communicated to the Governor and Members of 
the Council of Bombay. 
Towards the end of 1873 (after I had entered the 
service of Government on the yth April of that year) my 
father went to Baroda to make private inquiries regarding 
the misconduct of the Gaekwar's Brahmin servants of 
various grades. He took me with him, and thus early 
in my official career I gained considerable knowledge of 
Baroda and Gujarat affairs, and saw clearly enough that the 
Brahmins, even without making themselves too prominent, 
completely controlled the Gaekwar and the administration 
of his city and territory. This insight proved of great 
value to me in 1879, when I was in charge of a Kathiawar 
prant^ in which province there were several Gaekwari 
Mahals administered by Baroda officials, who also collected 
the tribute due to the Gaekwar by certain Kathiawar States. 
In 1879 I was appointed Acting Fourth Assistant 
Political Agent, in charge of the Jhalawad prant (division 
or province) of Kathiawar. This appointment was made 
by Sir Richard Temple, without the "particular sanction" 
of Her Majesty's Secretary of State for India, as required 
by Rule 33oC of the Civil Service Regulations. In 1880 
I was squeezed out of this Fourth Assistantship by the 
return of the permanent holder of the post, Major H. L. 
Nutt. Major Nutt had been appointed to act for two years 
as First Assistant Resident, Baroda, but was removed from 
16 UNDER THE FLAG 
that position for having, it was rumoured, personally 
assaulted the Resident, Mr. P. S. Melvill, I.C.S., in his 
residency. 
I was the sole sufferer by this ill-timed occurrence, 
inasmuch as it occasioned the cessation of my acting duties in 
Kathiawar, and thereby afforded the "Competition- Wallahs", 
then rising into power at the Secretariat, the desired 
opportunity of forcing me out of the Political Service. 
This opposition and hostility to the employment of an un- 
covenanted official in the higher posts of a Government 
department in India necessitated my rejoining the Marine 
Postal Service between Bombay and Suez. 
My patron, Sir Richard Temple, Governor of Bombay, 
heard of this hardship and predicament on about the 4th 
March, 1880, and he at once directed his chief secretary to re- 
arrange the duties of political officers in such a manner as 
would provide for Major Nutt elsewhere, without ousting 
me from the Kathiawar political agency. Sir Richard also 
asked the Government of India to allow me to act as 
First Assistant at Baroda vice Major Nutt, and instructed 
his private secretary, Mr. G. H. R. Hart, to tell me to stop 
at Baroda, on my way to Bombay, and call on Mr. Melvill, 
the Resident, to solicit his support to the proposal to 
transfer me to Baroda. 
Mr. Melvill when I called on him was not cordial, nor 
even officially courteous. He at once threw in my face 
that I was an uncovenanted officer, and as such ineligible 
by the regulations to hold a gazetted office in the Indian 
Political Service, from which I had been very properly 
ousted. He added that, after his recent experience with 
Major Nutt, he would oppose the appointment to Baroda 
of any officer of the Bombay Political Department. He 
did not offer me any hospitality, and allowed me to return 
to the railway station in the hired trap which I had picked 
up there to take me to the residency. I got a meal at the 
refreshment room, and took the first train to Bombay. 
Unfortunately for me, Sir Richard Temple had suddenly 
resigned the governorship, and left Bombay for Europe on 
the 1 3th March, 1 880. There was therefore no one person- 
ally to advise me as to my course of action, or to appeal 
BARODA 17 
on my behalf to the local government. The Acting 
Governor, moreover, who was a covenanted Indian Civil 
Servant, declined to grant me a personal interview. 
About a month later Mr. Melvill went to Europe in 
the P. & O. mail steamer of which I happened to be the 
mail agent. Walking into my empty office on deck, Mr. 
Melvill took a chair without an invitation from anyone. 
I found him there, and at once asked him to leave the 
office, as passengers, unless guests of the mail agent, were 
not admitted into it. To me it seemed that I was getting 
quits with Mr. Melvill for his treatment of me in his 
residency ! I related the foregoing incident to Sir Richard 
Temple and to Sir Henry Rawlinson, as evidence of the 
hostility of covenanted civilians to those who are locally 
known as bearing the "mark of the beast". I suggested 
that it should be privately mentioned to the Secretary of 
State, and also to Sir James Fergusson, Bart., the outgoing 
Governor of Bombay. Sir Richard Temple mentioned 
this matter to Sir James. 
In 1889 General A. G. F. Hogg, C.B., Resident at Aden, 
showed me a personal letter he had received, asking him 
to ascertain from me if I desired to act as First Assistant 
Resident at Baroda. The General observed that if I 
accepted the offer I would be serving under my cousin, 
Sir Harry Prendergast, V.C. ; and that, no doubt, I needed 
a change to comparatively healthy India, after so long a 
service in the exhausting climate of Aden and on the 
Somali coast. I replied that I wanted promotion in the 
Aden residency. I explained that I applied to go to India for 
the limited period of six months, and made it clear that I 
desired to continue at Aden as the permanent Second 
Assistant. The reason for this was that, being on the spot, 
the consulship and administratorship of Berbera and Zeila 
would fall to me in ordinary routine, when as Second 
Assistant I became the First Assistant Resident of Aden. 
The First Assistant Resident was always ex officio H.B.M/s 
consul and the political agent for the Somali coast, but if 
at any time the Foreign Office handed over Somaliland to 
the British Colonial Office, Indian political officers would 
no longer be employed in Somahland. If, therefore, I 
B 
1 8 UNDER THE FLAG 
were there, or at Aden, as the de facto First Assistant when 
the actual transfer took place, I was practically certain to 
become a permanent servant of the British Foreign Office, a 
position which I desired to hold. It would, consequently, 
not suit me to quit the service of the Aden residency, and 
I would rather remain his (General Hogg's) permanent 
Second Assistant, and have his support for my claim to 
become H.B.M.'s representative in Somaliland when that 
post fell vacant, than to go to Baroda as First Assistant, or 
to any assistantship elsewhere in India. 
In May 1893 General Hogg said that he had already 
written to Major Evelyn Baring, H.B.M.'s Consul-General 
in Egypt. General Hogg added that he had personally 
seen Mr. Julian Pauncefoot (and also had written to him, 
for demi-official record at the Foreign Office in London) 
about my future employment under the British Govern- 
ment. I could only thank General Hogg for his great 
kindness to me, and asked him to stop privately my being 
offered the Baroda opening, as I had no desire to have 
placed on record my refusal of that appointment, acting 
or permanent. 
CHAPTER HI 
"A STRONG MAN ARMED" 
I WAS brought up from my earliest childhood by Colonel 
and Mrs. Stather, who, after my mother's death at sea on 
the z6th March, 1862, were my guardians, and with whom 
I resided for many years. This dear, lovable old couple 
regarded me as their son. Mrs. Stather had no children 
of her own, and Colonel Stather's four daughters by his 
first marriage were grown up and out in the world. 
In these circumstances, during my boyhood I gradually 
acquired from my guardians some appreciation of the 
political affairs, conditions, and ideas of western India. 
Colonel Stather died on the 2yth February, 1893, and I had 
in that year completed over twenty years' service under 
Government. During that period I was frequently on 
leave in England, and I always visited him at his home in 
Gloucestershire. I sought his opinions on a variety of 
Indian subjects. For instance, I specially asked his views 
on the exercise by the East India Company of the laws of 
"Adoption" and "Lapse", and, as it happened, I had at that 
time to deal personally with some cases of "Adoption". His 
replies were very apposite, and of considerable help to me. 
Colonel Stather was an experienced officer, who thor- 
oughly understood native ways and their mode of thought; 
moreover, he was an untiring student of the history of 
India. 
In 1 8 5 3, at Baroda, my mother had taken the only suitable 
bungalow available, which, unfortunately, was situated near 
the cantonment boundary, neighbouring the city. The 
distance from the lines and the mess-house made this 
abode inconvenient, but on the other hand it was a com- 
modious and comfortable residence. Here on the 2 3 rd May, 
1854, my mother gave birth to her first child a strong, 
healthy infant, who received the names of Spencer John 
20 UNDER THE FLAG 
George Walsh. The orderly, Raghoo, was specially 
devoted to this baby. However, notwithstanding the 
skill of the regimental surgeon-major (Dr. Stile), and the 
loving care of the mother and Mrs. Stather, Spencer 
succumbed to croup on the 20th August, 1855. 
Colonel and Mrs. Stather, and Raghoo, have told me 
that my mother's grief was terrible to behold. Although 
she was in bad health, she insisted (contrary to Dr. Stile's 
advice) on going to the cemetery, and was driven to the 
child's grave by Mrs. Stather, instead of making use of the 
Resident's or the Gaekwar's carriage. Major Stather and 
my father carried the dead child's coffin to the grave ; and 
the orderlies, Raghoo and Abdool, attended the funeral in 
full uniform, saluting the coffin as it was being lowered to 
its last resting-place. Neither of these men had ever previ- 
ously witnessed a Christian burial, but when they observed 
the mourners sprinkling earth on the coffin they did like- 
wise. Major Stather, in speaking of these two Grenadier 
privates (one a Maratha, the other a Deccani Mohammedan), 
said that, although different from us in race, colour, and 
creed, they allowed no caste rules or prejudices to interfere 
with the public exhibition of their love and devotion to 
my parents. The fact remains that there was a strong 
bond of union between them and my father, owing to both 
being soldiers ; and they sympathized with him and with 
Mrs. Walsh, as the wife of a young Jung Bahadur Sahib. 
I was my mother's second child, and arrived about 
ten months before Colonel and Mrs. Stather retired on 
pension to Europe in 1856. A great intimacy and firm 
friendship had sprung up between my mother and Mrs. 
Stather. I had only a few infantile maladies, nevertheless 
my mother was anxious to send me to England, and for 
her sake Mrs. Stather offered to take care of me. This was 
a great relief to my mother, and Major Stather assured my 
father that as he and Mrs. Stather had no child of their own, 
he would like to take charge of me and bring me up with 
the soldiering instincts of a Grenadier. My father was 
delighted with this arrangement, which both before and * 
after my mother's death was carried out until I was sent 
to school in France. 
"A STRONG MAN ARMED" 21 
My mother lost her third child, George Inverarity Walsh 
(born the yth October, 1857 ; died the 23rd May, 1859), and, 
being seriously ill herself, started for England, taking me 
and the orderly, Raghoo, with her. I see, in a letter written 
by Lady George Houlton, that we arrived direct from 
Southampton at her residence in Somersetshire on the ist 
November, 1859. From there we went to see Colonel and 
Mrs. Stather at their hospitable home at Woodchester, 
near Stroud, and in their care I was to be placed, after my 
mother had shown me to her father in Ireland and to my 
paternal grandfather in England. 
These inspections and introductions completed, I was 
taken charge of by my mother's aunt, Miss Ellen Slator, 
Raghoo remaining in attendance on my mother, or making 
himself useful to her father at his rectory, while she paid 
visits to her friends and relations in Ireland and in England. 
It had been arranged that Raghoo would return to India 
with my mother on the ist October, 1860, and until that date 
he stayed with Colonel Stather. Being unable to talk 
English, he kept up my knowledge of "bad" Hindustani, 
or, as he called that language, "Laskhari". My mother 
started for India on the date fixed, and I remained with 
my great-aunt, Miss Ellen Slator, daughter of the Rector 
of Naas and of Tonyn, County Longford. 
I reached Woodchester in April 1861. Colonel 
Stather took me in hand at once, telling me that he intended 
to make me a Grenadier. That intention had rejoiced 
Raghoo, and made him predict that one day I would com- 
mand that famous pultan. Years later Colonel Stather 
told me that Raghoo said : "May I be spared to see the 
Baba Sahib dress a company of our old regiment, and may 
he command the corps." 
Colonel Stather put me up on a pony, and taught 
me to ride and to jump that handy little animal over 
bushes and obstacles erected in the paddock, and I soon got 
over the falling-off stage. Colonel Stather attached the 
greatest importance to the noble art of self-defence. He 
pointed out the advantage of hitting straight from the 
shoulder, and of knowing how to use the point of a 
sword. He held that it was never too early to teach these 
zz UNDER THE FLAG 
exercises to a child, and daily I was put through a 
regular curriculum of defensive and offensive methods 
and tactics. 
When I was about six years of age Miss Emily Stather 
(who had taught me my alphabet) asked her father to let 
me read to him a few verses of the Bible. He consented, 
afterwards patting me on the head and giving me sixpence. 
But at the same time he observed : "That is no doubt 
useful, but it is more essential to be able to hit hard with 
your fists, and to use a sword or spear, mounted or on foot. 
With that equipment a man can make his way and earn 
his crust anywhere as an efficient man-at-arms under the 
British fllag." 
Four years of Colonel Stather's method of training 
made me for my age, she, and weight a formidable opponent. 
Once two village boys attacked me, one bigger an d the 
other smaller than myself. However, I stood to fight 
it out, and systematically went for my biggest adversary. 
Eventually I knocked him down, and there was no more 
fight left in him. My smaller opponent ran away, but not 
before I had been severely punished by this little imp. I 
had started off in pursuit of my smaller antagonist, when 
Colonel Stather appeared and called me back. I remon- 
strated by saying, "That cowardly devil has got off scot- 
free, as I was quite unable to devote any of my attention 
to him." Colonel Stather said, "That is so, but the day 
is yours. You have nearly killed the chap you have laid 
out, and we shall have serious trouble with his parents. 
Fortunately, however, there are several women witnesses, 
who will testify as to who caused, commenced, and provoked 
the fight." I replied, "Both boys laughed at and ridiculed 
my clothes. I took no notice of their impudence, but then 
the big fellow hit me and observed, 'Take that !' which I did, 
on my nose !" "My dear Langton," the Colonel answered, 
"you have behaved well. But what I liked best of all is your 
judgment in going at all costs to yourself for the big chap. 
I shall write and tell your father that you are shaping very 
well to become a Grenadier." 
Colonel Stather led me off to the kitchen, and asked 
the cook to wash me up and place some raw meat over my 
"A STRONG MAN ARMED" 23 
eyes and on my cuts and bruises. Mrs. Stather happened 
to come into the kitchen, and seeing my condition, and my 
two lovely black eyes, scolded her husband, accusing him 
of teaching and encouraging me to fight. The Colonel said, 
"You are a little unfair, Mary. Langton was gratuitously 
attacked, and defended himself skilfully, in a way which 
becomes the son of a gentleman." The Colonel was 
bundled out of the kitchen, and I was petted and patched 
up. I was then told not to fight, which I had no occasion 
to do again at Woodchester, as I was never molested by 
any boy in the village. 
Although only a young child, I thoroughly understood 
Colonel Stather's precepts and advice, namely not to 
bully anyone, but at once and resolutely to resent anyone, 
big or small, who tried to bully me. As the Colonel pointed 
out, if I was known to possess the character for prompt 
action in such cases, I should always be left in peace. The 
whole of my experience has convinced me of the correctness 
of my guardian's ideas. They were identical with the 
teachings of our Lord Jesus Christ on the subject of "a 
strong man armed" (see St. Luke xi, 21, and xxii, 36), and 
should be instilled into every child. Holding such views, 
Colonel Stather insisted on my being trained as a child to 
box and to use a sword. 
I made a point, whenever in England, of visiting my 
old friend and guardian at Woodchester. In 1882-83 I 
came home after the campaign in Egypt, having been 
mentioned in despatches, much to the delight of Colonel 
Stather and his wife. Sir Herbert MacPherson, command- 
ing the Indian Regiment in Egypt, suggested to the 
Military Secretary, Colonel Dillon, that a commission 
should be tendered to me. At my age it would have been 
folly for me to accept it. Nevertheless, the official offer 
of a commission served to strengthen my case, as Sir Henry 
Rawlinson could use Sir Herbert's despatch in support of 
my claim on the Government of India for my restoration 
to the Political Service. This Her Most Gracious Majesty 
had been pleased to order, but that reward did not 
terminate the opposition of the trade union corps in 
Bombay. 
24 UNDER THE FLAG 
Mrs. Mary Caruthers Stather, aged 73 years, died at 
Woodchester on the 24th September, 1884, and is buried in 
the churchyard of that parish. 
Lieut.-Colonel William Carlisle Stather, aged 85 years, 
died on the 2yth February, 1893, and is buried alongside 
his wife. 
CHAPTER IV 
BOYHOOD DAYS 
NEARLY every year I visited both of my grandfathers. My 
mother's father, the Reverend William Spencer Walsh, 
D.D., had served in a Dragoon regiment before taking 
Holy Orders. When he discovered that I could ride and 
box, he had the highest admiration of Colonel Stather's 
methods of bringing me up. The old man was himself a 
horseman of repute, and in his youth had been a member of 
the Kilruddery Hunt. 
I also stayed with my paternal grandfather, the Reverend 
John Prendergast Walsh, M.A., who had served with the 
95th Rifles (now the Rifle Brigade) at Waterloo, and had 
changed his green jacket for the more sedate raiments and 
robes of an evangelical cleric of the Church of England. 
He was known on retirement from the Service as "Timber- 
leg", and had left the Army for the express purpose of oppos- 
ing Puseyism on the platform and in the pulpit. He was 
the owner of the advowson of a church-living in Somerset- 
shire, but did not himself hold a benefice. He resided per- 
manently abroad, chiefly in France, visiting England during 
the summer months of each year. This grandfather took 
a house called "Les Tourelles" (the old semaphore station), 
in the Boulevard du Sud, at Avranches, in Normandy. 
I was placed as an externe at the Lycee Imperiale. 
There were no English boys at this college, where I rapidly 
learned to speak French fluently and with the same pro- 
nunciation as spoken by my camarades cfecole. My 
grandfather was very intimate with an old Napoleonic 
officer called Le Capitaine Comte de Soule. This gentleman 
belonged to the noblesse^ and owned a small estate in 
Brittany. He hated the Napoleonists, and when asked 
why he had so loyally served the great Napoleon, he used 
to reply, "Mafoi, H etait soldat !" 
26 UNDER THE FLAG 
My grandparents had to go on business to England for 
a few weeks. Not knowing what to do with me, they 
placed me as an interne in the Lycee Imperiale. There a 
boy rather bigger and physically stronger than myself 
called me "un cochon d? Anglais" ; and no doubt in reply 
I expressed my opinion of him individually, and of his 
compatriots generally. At any rate, my remarks infuriated 
all present against me, but fortunately I had closed with 
my opponent, to prevent his coups de pied reaching me, and 
I took his head into "chancery" with my right arm. My 
many assailants beat me very severely about the head, 
right shoulder and arms, in order to make me let go. But 
I hung on, and bore the consequent punishment. By 
attacking me on my right side, they allowed me entire 
freedom to play with my left fist, with which I planted a 
succession of well-directed blows above and below the 
eyes, and on the nose and mouth of the Mew. My opponent 
could not shake me off, and I presented him with several 
souvenirs, nearly all delivered on the same spot, until I 
became exhausted by my own efforts. 
When we were separated by some of the under-masters, 
I was marched off and placed before the proviseur, who 
heard the complaint made against me and saw the bruised 
features of my late opponent. The proviseur, without 
hearing me at all, called me "un maroufle" and "un enfant 
terrible et feroce", and threatened me with solitary confine- 
ment. The concierge, however (to whom my grandfather 
had occasionally given a douceur, with an injunction to look 
after me), seeing that I had got into serious trouble, com- 
municated at once with Captain Soule, my grandfather's 
old friend, who had brought me to the Lycee Imperiale. 
Captain Soule thereupon drove at once to the college, and 
was shown into the room in which the proviseur was 
holding forth on my brutality. 
Captain Soule listened to this tirade, and then asked for 
explanations. Seeing that I had a friend to take my part, 
I exhibited my injuries, rolling up the sleeve of my 
bloodstained shirt and showing my right shoulder. I 
also drew attention to the lumps and clots of blood on 
my head, of which the proviseur had not been aware, or 
BOYHOOD DAYS 27 
had not chosen to notice. Captain Soule therefore asked 
for my version of the fracas, and it received some corrobor- 
ative evidence from obviously hostile witnesses. I was 
allowed to go, and sent to be cared for by the Sisters who 
conducted the college infirmary. There I was treated with 
the greatest kindness, being called "un pauvre petit" without 
a mother, and whose father was in India. 
These circumstances gained me a lot of sympathy, and 
Madame, the wife of the proviseur^ who regularly visited 
the sick-wards of the infirmary, was brought by one of the 
Sisters to see me. This lady was very kind, and as I was 
the only English boy in the college, she had heard all about 
me, and announced at once that her husband was quite 
wrong in styling me "un enfant terrible et feroce". I was 
asked to come and see her and her daughter as soon as I 
was discharged from the infirmary. I accepted, and often 
availed myself of that kind and hospitable invitation. 
Moreover, now that I was personally known to Monsieur 
le Proviseur I got on very well with him, but I have often 
wondered what would have happened to me if Captain 
Soule had not been there to protect me. 
At the beginning of 1865, or late in 1864, I left the 
Lyce"e at Avranches, and after a short stay with Colonel 
Stather at Woodchester I was sent to Davenport's School 
at 20, Rue de Maguetra, Boulogne-sur-Mer. Some months 
later I went to Avranches again, for the express purpose of 
visiting Captain Soule, to hear his reminiscences of the 
Napoleonic Wars, in which he had been engaged, his stories 
of Waterloo, the Campaign of 1815, and his partings with 
the great Emperor at Fontainebleau and Malmaison. 
Early in March 1865, or late in 1864, I left the Lycee. 
I bade adieu to Captain Soule, who put me in the dili- 
gence for Granville, where I took a passage on board the 
s.s. Comet for Southampton. She touched at Jersey and 
Guernsey, and landed me after a very comfortable passage 
at my destination. Although only a young child, yet, by 
always having to find my own way about, I had become an 
experienced traveller; and, taking a cab at Waterloo, I 
had no difficulty in getting to Netting Hill Gate, where 
my father, late in 1862, had taken a furnished house, which 
28 UNDER THE FLAG 
he had placed in charge of his sister, Miss Euphemia 
Walsh, who later became the wife of Captain Townsend 
Tyndall of the Bombay Army. My aunt had the care of 
my two sisters and her father, the Reverend J. Prendergast 
Walsh, and his wife ; while my mother's aunt, Miss Ellen 
Slator, the daughter of the Reverend James Slator, of 
Tonyn, Co. Longford, and Vicar of Naas, was constantly 
staying with her. 
While at Woodchester with the Stathers I frequently 
came up to see my relatives, and also my father and his 
second wife. And as a small boy I met at my aunt's 
house several notable and interesting people. In 1864 
she took my sisters to Boulogne-sur-Mer, and later on to 
Paris. 
My father and his wife entertained a good deal. And 
as they kept a mail phaeton and a pair of horses, I was 
often taken to the Park by my stepmother and introduced 
to my father's friends and acquaintances in many parts of 
London. Although, in fact, an infant at the time, yet I 
recollect the names of some of those who frequently came 
to my father's house. I did not, of course, understand 
the subjects which were often discussed in my presence, 
but I have since studied the bearings of some of them from 
my father's papers. 
General Sir Robert Napier, R.E., was a frequent visitor. 
Later he became Commander-in-Chief, Bombay, and 
conducted the operations during the campaign in Abyssinia. 
In recognition of his war service, he was raised to the 
peerage as Baron of Magdala and Caryngton. 
I remember the Princess Victoria Guaramma, daughter 
of the Raja of Coorg. The Princess was a Christian and 
a godchild of H.M. Queen Victoria. She married a 
Colonel John Campbell, of the 38th Madras Native Infantry. 
She was always handsomely dressed, and wore valuable 
jewellery. She frequently took me to the Park in her 
well-appointed carriage, and loaded me with presents and 
large packets of sweets. In consequence, when up from 
Woodchester, I never failed to let her know of my presence 
in London. 
The Princess died in 1864, and there is a curious story 
BOYHOOD DAYS 29 
regarding her husband's fate. My father was well acquain- 
ted with Colonel Campbell, and both were members 
of the Oriental Club, Hanover Square, London. Colonel 
Campbell was seen to enter that club on the yth August, 1867, 
but no evidence of his leaving it could be traced. My 
father never had any reason for supposing that Colonel 
Campbell was hard up, but during his wife's lifetime he 
once observed to my father : "The Princess has a quantity 
of valuable gems, rings, stones, and pearls, which are useless 
to her, but for sentimental reasons and traditions she does 
not desire to sell them." My father said it was generally 
supposed that, after the death of Princess Victoria, some, 
if not the whole, of these costly articles had passed person- 
ally to Colonel Campbell, and it had been suggested that, 
as one of the gems in his possession was the stolen eye of 
an idol, the chief pugari of the temple owning that idol 
desired to restore this precious stone to the place from which 
it had been removed. This gem, being the property of 
neither the State nor the last reigning Raja of Coorg, 
could not, therefore, be legally retained in the safe keeping 
of his daughter, the Princess Victoria of Coorg. 
There is absolutely no evidence to support this tale, 
but a novel called The Moonstone refers to a story of a some- 
what similar nature. It would be quite feasible to send 
an emissary to London to recover, by fair means or foul, 
the sacred idol's lost eye, especially as in this case it was 
known that Colonel Campbell was not unwilling to sell 
some, or all, of the jewellery in his custody. In such 
circumstances it would be quite a simple matter to invite 
him to bring this particular gem for the inspection of a 
potential purchaser ; while if he had been thus enticed to 
exhibit that jewel, he could have been easily murdered, and 
his body secretly buried or burned, with little risk to the 
perpetrators of such a crime. 
The Maharajah Dhulip Singh, the son of Rumjit 
Singh, "the lion of the Punjab", constantly came to my 
father's house to consult him about his claims, debts, and 
difficulties. My father personally endeavoured to induce 
the Secretary of State, the Prime Minister, and other influ- 
ential personages to relieve the Maharajah of his debts, and 
30 UNDER THE FLAG 
to increase his annual pension. I did not see the Maharajah 
Dhulip Singh again until he was detained by the Secretary 
of State's orders at Aden in 1886, when he told me of his 
impoverished condition and his inability to get any kind 
of redress from the British Government. Dhulip Singh 
said to me : "I have often used the examples and arguments 
which your father contended should govern my 'case and 
claims'." 
Shortly before his death I wrote to several senior 
officials at the India Office, with whom I was personally 
acquainted, to get the Maharajah a pittance for the relief of 
his immediate necessities. However, nothing was done 
for him. He died in abject poverty in Paris, on the 
23rd October, 1893. 
Mr. Harris Prendergast, Q.C., a bencher of Lincoln's 
Inn, was closely related to my father. I was taken to his 
house to be introduced to my cousin, and my first observa- 
tion to him was : "You are the first Prendergast cousin 
I have ever seen." In reply he tipped me ten shillings, and 
desired me not to forget him. I never did, and my sisters 
and I often went to have tea at his house in Talbot Square, 
Paddington. Mr. Harris Prendergast was a student of 
and an expert adviser on, all matters connected with the 
rights and privileges of military officers. His knowledge 
on that question is disclosed in his book entitled The Law 
delating to Officers in the Army. 
On the death in 1868 of Mr. Davenport, the principal 
of the school I attended at Boulogne-sur-Mer, my class- 
master, Monsieur Destre, had to find employment as an 
under-teacher in some other school. Having an eye to 
business, it struck him that he could easily obtain the post 
he required by offering his services to Monsieur Le Petit, 
the proprietor and principal of the school at 15, Rue 
Flauhaut. He could also casually let drop to that peda- 
gogue that, although nearly all Mr. Davenport's pupils 
were returning to England, yet he believed ten or twelve 
English boys desired to continue their studies under him 
in France,'? and that several of the latter would in all 
probability join the school in which he had the promise 
of employment. Monsieur Le Petit readily "tumbled" 
BOYHOOD DAYS 31 
to this suggestion, and on the spot offered to Monsieur 
Destre the same status in his school as he had held under 
Mr. Davenport. I at once wrote to Colonel Stather, asking 
to be placed at Monsieur Le Petit's school, as the best way 
of keeping up my knowledge of that language. My 
guardian assented to this view, and accordingly arranged 
to have me transferred to 15, Rue de Flauhaut. 
At Davenport's school we wore plain clothes ; but at 
Le Petit's school all the pupils were attired in the tenue 
of a French ecole, or college, the sole difference being 
the device on the buttons of our garments. In a few days 
I was dressed as un eleve, with a kepi, a dark blue jacket, 
waistcoat and trousers to match, and was quite delighted 
with my uniform. 
At Boulogne I met a remarkable and well-known man, 
by name Mr. Launcelot Peyton, who for years was very 
kind to me, and took me about with him everywhere. He 
lived at Boulogne with his wife, and, having no children, 
they desired to adopt me altogether. They went so far 
as to approach Colonel Stather and my paternal grand- 
mother with that proposal, which, of course, could not 
be entertained. At the same time, however, it was so 
genuine and so nicely made that they both thanked Mr. 
Peyton for it ; and they were very glad that I had such a 
good and desirable friend during my lonely schooldays 
in France. 
I never heard Mr. Launcelot Peyton himself claim any 
military rank, but he was always addressed as Captain, or 
Colonel, or even General Peyton, and he was supposed to 
have had a regular commission in the American Confederate 
Army. He had been a man of large wealth, the owner 
of several plantations worked by two or three thousand 
slaves. He never sold or bought a slave, but they bred 
naturally on his large landed estates, where each one had a 
hut and a "cabbage patch". "Colonel" Peyton, as I have 
always called him, lost in the service of the Southern 
Confederacy the whole of his immense fortune and 
property, and it was only by an exceptional stroke of pure 
good luck that he recovered a considerable portion of 
the money he had advanced to the cause of the Southern 
32 UNDER THE FLAG 
States in their war against the Northern States of the 
Union. 
Colonel Peyton was sent to Europe to arrange for the 
conveyance by "blockade runners" of stores for the 
Confederate Government. For that purpose he had a 
large sum of money in London under his sole control, but 
was suddenly instructed by his Government to cease all 
operations on their behalf, and to apply the money in part 
payment of the debt due to him. By this means he came 
into possession of funds, which he invested, and lived on 
the income derived from that source, which I estimate as 
yielding several thousand pounds per annum. 
CHAPTER V 
ODSEY GRANGE AND COWLEY 
MY father took a lease of Odsey Grange, an old-fashioned 
but commodious house situated about half-way between 
Baldock and Royston, and about two miles by road from 
the village of Ashwell. Mr. Herbert Fordham, of Odsey 
House, owned the Grange, also a large number of acres 
around it, on which game was preserved and afforded ex- 
cellent sport. My father and his wife attended the "meets" 
of the various packs of hounds in the vicinity, and he 
was invited by the neighbouring landowners to shoot in 
their preserves. 
I spent my holidays at Odsey Grange, and had a good 
time there. Many hunting men, seeing that I could ride, 
lent me a mount whenever I wanted one ; moreover, as 
my father had three hunters, and two other crocks, I rarely 
lacked a nag to ride. A Mr. Nash, who maintained a pack 
of harriers (this gentleman, later, I believe, married Miss 
Constance Fordham of Odsey House), and the two brothers 
Merry of Guilden Morden, kept a number of hunters, 
while a Mr. Gentil, pork butcher and horse-dealer, nearly 
always had a "likely nag" for sale. From one or other 
of these stables I could always get a mount for a meet. 
Mr. Gentil, however, made it a condition that I should not 
injure his animal's feet on a hard road. 
My visits to Odsey Grange gave me an insight into 
English rural life and etiquette with a pack in the field, of 
whith I had no previous knowledge. It also taught me to 
ride and stick on the back of a horse, which experience was 
of great service to me during my varied career in the 
East. 
My father accompanied me to Cowley College, Oxford, 
in July or August 1869. On arrival there he was told that 
the principal resided in Oxford, and was not then on the 
33 r* 
34 UNDER THE FLAG 
premises. However, the head master, the Reverend 
J. G. Watts, M.A., would see us in about ten minutes, 
when he came out of the classroom. 
Sergeant Kent, a drill instructor and in charge of the 
college batmen, was obviously an old soldier. He had met 
us at the door, and invited my father to follow the maid to the 
matron's parlour, where Kent handed the matron my father's 
card. The matron was a handsome, middle-aged widow, 
and received us politely. She suggested that while we 
waited for the head master and chaplain, Sergeant Kent 
should show my father over the premises, which consisted 
of the Old House, the brick buildings, and the new 
(stone) buildings and chapel. My father tipped Kent a 
sovereign, and said to him : "Look after my boy, Sergeant. 
He has been brought up in schools in France, and no doubt 
has some foreign ways and manners. He is therefore 
likely to be teased, laughed at, and possibly bullied. Now 
I don't want you, or anyone, to interfere on his behalf. He 
can take very good care of himself, and has been shown 
and trained since four years of age to use his fists. It 
will surprise me if a boy of his size, weight, and age can 
take him on successfully even a bigger one will soon 
find out what he is up against." 
Sergeant Kent suggested that I should be placed in the 
Gloucestershire room, where my companions would be 
Mr. Chetwynd and two brothers named Boyes, sons of a 
rector whose brother was an admiral. Sergeant Kent 
regarded these boys as desirable "nobs". His daughter, 
Constance, a girl of about nineteen years of age, was the 
chambermaid of the Gloucestershire room, and my father 
gave her a small present. Thus, from my start at Cowley, 
I secured two very useful and devoted friends. My father 
had a short interview with Mr. Watts, who introduced us 
to his wife, and it appeared to me that I should get on very 
well with the head master. We were conducted back to 
the matron's parlour, and Sergeant Kent had told us that 
she was a near relative of the principal. Moreover, her 
son, who resided with his mother and attended the college 
classes, was French in all respects, his deceased father 
having been a French Army officer, who had been an 
ODSEY GRANGE AND COWLEY 35 
A.D.C. and assistant private secretary to the Governor- 
General of French Algeria. 
After my father had left the college to catch a train for 
London, as the quickest way of getting back to Odsey 
Grange, I wandered alone into the quadrangle and play- 
ground. There, of course, I was spotted as a "new boy", 
and had to stand a little good-natured chaff. One boy, 
however, insisted on calling me "Frenchy", and "a d 
frog-eater". I assured him that I was Irish, but had been 
educated in France, and that I had no relish for the 
delicacy to which he had alluded. Nevertheless, he 
repeated the above abusive epithets, and it struck me that 
my new comrades were watching to see if I would put up 
with it. In these circumstances, I felt compelled to act. 
I said to my aggressor : "I have already told you that I 
am not French. But since you persist in disbelieving me on 
that point, I must provide you with evidence in support 
of my assertion." I made that remark calmly, and with- 
out exhibiting any heat or temper. He himself then 
struck out at me, and I lost no time in returning the attack. 
As he had exposed himself, I landed him a right-hander 
between the eyes, and, being the taller and stronger, he 
tried to close with me. At that, by good luck, I caught 
him fairly with my left. The weight of this blow, added 
to his own impetus, upset his equilibrium and caused him 
to fall sideways. Getting up speedily, he gallantly renewed 
the fight. He attempted to rush me, and, thereby again 
exposing himself, he received three or four well-placed 
left-handers at close quarters. By those scientifically 
planted blows he was completely beaten, and gave up the 
fight. 
My opponent's injuries had to be attended to in the 
infirmary, but there was no bad blood between us, and 
we soon became very intimate and dear friends. Here 
I may observe that during the rest of my time at Cowley 
I never had occasion to fight anyone. I owed my success 
to Colonel Stathers' training and principles, which, 
besides being sound, are those of a gentleman. 
Sergeant Kent witnessed the fight from afar, but, 
recollecting my father's wishes, he did not attempt to stop 
36 UNDER THE FLAG 
it, as it was his duty to do. After the scrimmage was over, 
he went to report it to the Reverend England, the master 
on duty for the day, and stated the facts of the case faith- 
fully enough, but also placed them in a favourable light 
for me. I had evidently gone up in Sergeant Kent's 
estimation. A little later he came to me and, saluting in 
the correct Service way, said : "Mr. England, the senior 
class-master of division two, wishes to see you, sir." He 
conducted me to the master's parlour, where I found the 
Rev. Mr. England seated in a chair at his writing-table. 
I put my heels together, saluted, and then stood at 
attention in French fashion. Mr. England said : "You 
have been fighting. Are you not aware that fighting is 
absolutely prohibited ?" I respectfully denied that I had 
been fighting, pointing out that my clothes were not even 
deranged. I then explained that a boy had called me a 
"frog-eating Frenchy", and would not believe my assertion 
that I was Irish. I was therefore, I said, compelled to 
provide evidence of the truth of my statement, and the boy 
was no longer in doubt of my Celtic origin. Mr. England 
smiled and said : "You must never again furnish that kind 
of evidence here." I apologized, and expressed regret at 
having transgressed the rules of the college. Whereupon 
Mr. England invited me to sit down and explain how and 
where I had been brought up. I told him, and was glad 
to have so early an opportunity of doing so. 
There were three other under-masters in the room, one 
of them the professor of French. He spoke to me in his 
own language, and engaged me in conversation. Then, 
suddenly taking up a French book, he directed me to read 
from it the paragraph he had indicated. I readily complied, 
and monsieur declared that I should be put in the highest 
French class. I wanted to translate into English what I 
had read out, but I was not allowed to do so, although I 
protested I could render the passages in question. Mr. 
England answered me : "It is not necessary, as we all see, 
from the way you delivered them, that you thoroughly 
understood what you had read out." Monsieur also 
added : "Your knowledge of French would, under ordinary 
circumstances, put you at the top of the first class. But 
ODSEY GRANGE AND COWLEY 37 
I regret to tell you that, in my opinion, you will only take 
the second place. It will, I dare say, be a near thing, and 
as regards general knowledge you are a long way above 
your rival. The latter, however, happens to be French, 
and was educated entirely in France. He is also older than 
you, so you will stand little or no chance against him." 
I replied : "I have already met the pupil to whom you 
allude, and fully realize that he will be above me in the 
French class. I am really sorry at this misfortune, as now 
I shall not have the satisfaction of being certain of the top 
place of any class in the college." A bell rang, and, 
apologizing to the professor, I said, "Voila le tambour." 
The three Englishmen in the room were sufficiently con- 
versant of French to know that "tambour" meant a drum, 
but they considered me "dotty" until the professor 
explained to them that in French lycees bells, bugles, and 
trumpets were not used, all commands and directions being 
announced by beat or tap of the drum. I said good 
night to all present, and thought I had not created a bad 
impression on my new masters. Mr. England told me to 
see him the next day in the second division classroom half 
an hour before the pupils assembled there, and he would 
then examine me to decide as to the division and class in 
which he would recommend the head master to place me. 
I went off to bed in the Gloucestershire room, where I 
made the acquaintance of three very jolly stable com- 
panions. With one of them, Herbert Chetwynd, I have 
been a lifelong friend, and he was a constant visitor at 
my home until his death. The other two I lost sight of. 
I had a large cake and a quantity of fruit in my valise, which 
Constance had not disturbed, and I proceeded to share 
these "good things" with my new friends. I had been 
cautioned by Sergeant Kent that feasting in the bedrooms 
was against the regulations, and that a sneaking underling 
might creep upstairs to catch and report us. I told 
Chetwynd of this danger, and he said : "Yes, most probably. 
But we can frustrate an attempt to catch us. I have a 
plentiful supply of broken nutshells to strew on each of 
the treads of the staircase ; and I have also placed some 
other obstacles for a sneak to blunder over, thereby 
5 8 UNDER THE FLAG 
warning us of his presence." Probably these precautions 
protected us. Be that as it may, we ate our cake in peace. 
Next morning, however, the chambermaid complained 
of the mess we had made, which, if not cleared up at once, 
would get all of us into trouble with the head master. We 
expressed sorrow and gave her a liberal supply of cake, and 
it restored her equanimity. 
At Cowley College Mr. England befriended me in many 
ways, giving me some sound and useful advice, which I 
have followed with success to myself. I recollect his 
observing to me : "Memory and power to retain in the 
brain knowledge acquired by reading is very limited, 
especially as regards the details of an intricate subject. 
My advice to you, therefore, is not to waste time with 
questions unlikely to arise, but to be always mindful of 
where to refer and to find full particulars of any matter. 
Supply yourself on starting in life with a small portable 
reference library, and add to it whenever circumstances 
permit you to do so. Endeavour to gain experience as 
a scribe by writing paragraphs and announcements for the 
Press, but don't expect to be paid for such contributions. 
If you can induce an editor to publish your communica- 
tions|in the columns of his newspaper, it will amply repay 
you in the end. Endeavour, also, to become known as 
an authority on some particular subject or country. . . ." 
I have invariably followed and benefited by that advice. 
Cowley has no connection with the Cowley Fathers, 
beyond the fact that some members of that fraternity 
resided in that hamlet. In my own time there, for some 
reason or other, the villagers made an effigy, and intended 
to burn it on Bullingdon Green, close to the Cowley College 
cricket ground. The boys, as a whole, resented the burn- 
ing of an effigy of a minister of any religion ; but I believe 
I took a leading part in driving off the villagers, and in 
effecting the rescue of the effigy from its intended fate at 
the hands of these ignorant peasants. I obtained reinforce- 
ments from the college to recover the effigy, and we hung 
on to it and drove off our assailants. Mr. England highly 
approved of my views and action, as being what he called 
very proper behaviour in the matter. 
ODSEY GRANGE AND COWLEY 39 
There was no Cowley College Rowing Club, but several 
of the pupils had their own boats at Sandford Lock. There 
we could always hire an old "eight" for a scratch crew. On 
condition that we rejoined by train on the i6th July, 1870, 
some of us obtained permission to go downstream in the 
"eight" we had hired, and of which I was coxswain. We 
arranged to stop for two or three nights on the trip at 
River Bank Inn, and to hand over our boat to Messum, at 
Richmond, who would send it back by barge to Sandford. 
We arrived at Richmond and put up at the Talbot 
Hotel, facing the bridge. My grandfather and my father 
frequented that hotel, and for many years sat with a coterie 
of their friends, drinking port wine in a window over- 
looking the bridge. 
I should here mention that when I went to Cowley I 
had already some experience of boating, thanks to the 
kindness of some of my father's friends. At different 
times on the Thames I had learned to pull and feather an 
oar and generally to handle a boat, as well as how and to 
what part of a boat or barge a tow-line should be made 
fast for haulage purposes. It was entirely owing to such 
knowledge and experience that I was specially mentioned 
in the despatches of the Egyptian Campaign of 1882, while 
it was, of course, very useful to me at Cowley. Except 
on the Liane at Boulogne, where I merely paddled 
about anyhow, I never had any other kind of boat 
training. 
To return to the occasion of the jaunt of the Cowley 
eight on the i6th July, 1870. Each member of the crew 
wore the college cap, tie, and blazer, and, as I have said, we 
put up at the "Talbot", Richmond. There we were 
seated in the bar-room facing the street, when a foreigner 
went up to the counter and asked for a drink, which the 
barmaid handed to him. The foreigner then emptied on 
to the bar counter the contents of his overcoat pockets. 
I happened to notice that he had a watch-chain in the 
buttonhole of his great-coat, which he let loose. As the 
bar of his chain got through the buttonhole of his overcoat, 
no doubt he intended to place it (I presume it had a watch 
attached) on the counter, together with the pile of other 
40 UNDER THE FLAG 
articles from his pockets. Walking across the room, he 
hung up his greatcoat and then returned to the bar. 
Upon failing to see his watch, without making any search 
he rushed into the street and fetched in a constable of 
police. He accused the barmaid of having stolen his 
watch, which she denied ever having seen. The con- 
stable had no legal right to interfere, but this peeler marched 
off both the complainant and the accused to the nearest 
police-station. The crew of the Cowley eight followed ; 
and I acted to some extent as an interpreter, and wholly 
as an indignant spectator of the illegal arrest of an English 
girl without a warrant from a magistrate. 
The superintendent in charge of the station saw at 
once that the policeman had exceeded his duty ; neverthe- 
less, he endeavoured to shield the erring constable. The 
foreigner, who turned out to be a Frenchman, insisted that 
the barmaid should be locked up. That, of course, the 
superintendent could not do, and he finally referred the 
complainant to the court, as the charge was not cognizable 
by a policeman who had not himself seen the theft com- 
mitted and whose information was derived from the 
complainant's unsupported statement of the case. The 
court-house in question, where the petty sessions were 
being held, was in Paradise Road, Richmond. 
I was slightly acquainted with Mr. Francis (or Lt.- 
Colonel Sir Francis) Burdett, Bart., J.P., of Ancaster House, 
Richmond, a magistrate for the Richmond Division of 
Surrey, who happened to be in the vicinity of the police- 
station. I went up to him and explained the circumstances, 
but he said that until the case came up before the Bench 
he could not intervene in any way. Nevertheless, he spoke 
to the superintendent, and a little later the superintendent 
told the barmaid that she was free to go. This announce- 
ment was greeted with cheers by the members of the 
Cowley eight, and, indeed, by the crowd generally, and 
we escorted the maid back in triumph to the Talbot Hotel. 
Mr. and Mrs. Grunhold, the proprietors, thanked me 
profusely, and always attributed the release of their barmaid, 
and the hushing-up of the case, to my efforts in the matter. 
Their gratitude, indeed, was somewhat embarrassing, as 
ODSEY GRANGE AND COWLEY 41 
till the day of their death they would not allow me to pay 
for anything I might order in the hotel. 
The crew afterwards sat down to dinner, and decided 
that when they had handed the "eight" over to Messum 
whose store for boats, in those days, was under one of the 
arches of Richmond Bridge they would return next 
morning by an early train to Oxford. Later, the waiter 
came to the smoking-room with a telegram for me from 
my father. My father was then in lodgings in South 
Moulton Street ; his wife, with her mother, was at Ealing. 
The telegram ran : "Come at once to see me here." 
I managed to get to London that night, and the 
decision then made altered my intended career. Since 
then over fifty-five years have elapsed. Do I regret the 
decision ? No, I would act similarly now, with all my 
experiences. 
CHAPTER VI 
WAR CLOUDS 
ON my reaching London the night of the i6th July, 1870, 
my father told me it seemed to him that war between 
France and Prussia was now inevitable, as the French 
Minister had actually left Berlin. The French people 
demanded the immediate invasion of Germany, and this 
enterprise was supported by Marshal Le Bceuf, Chief of 
Staff of the French Army, and in attendance on the 
Emperor, as well as by Monsieur Emille Ollivier, Head of 
the Ministry. 
All parties and classes had resolved on war with 
Prussia, but, owing to the unpreparedness of the French 
Army, a delay in the date of the declaration of war was 
advised by the French Foreign Office. It was, indeed, 
also advised by Napoleon himself and some of his senior 
generals. Monsieur Thiers endeavoured to defer the 
commencement of hostilities solely on the grounds of it 
being premature to attack at this juncture ; however, he 
strongly advocated an early date for commencing hostilities 
as essential to the safety of France. 
It was hoped that French diplomacy would be able to 
gain time by averting an actual collision between the oppos- 
ing armies, and so, at least, bring about the neutrality of 
Austria, Italy, and even some of the southern States of 
Germany. The French were terribly disappointed at 
Bavaria joining Prussia, as the latter kingdom had been 
regarded by some as a possible French ally. The Emperor, 
however, was forced by public opinion, and by the fear of 
being driven off his throne, to declare war, regardless of 
whether his army was fit to take the field or not. 
My father's connection with the campaign arose in the 
following manner : 
A group of Indian and other newspapers decided to 
WAR CLOUDS 43 
have an expert writer as a correspondent of their own, and 
to attach him to one of the French Army Corps. Under 
the regulations, such a correspondent must be un officier 
de carriere on the Active List, and wear the uniform of his 
rank in the army to which he belonged. These restrictions 
favoured my father's chance, and he was selected as war 
correspondent. 
My father and I left London in the forenoon of the 
1 9th July, 1870. Arriving in Paris after an uneventful 
journey, we called on a Count Walsh de Serrant, at No. 7, 
Rue de la Baume. He was very kind, and gave us a 
letter to Marshal Canrobert, commanding the 6th French 
Army Corps, whom he knew intimately. Even with 
Count Walsh's personal assistance, my father had not been 
able to purchase a riding-horse in Paris, and his search 
for a couple of chargers revealed that the Government had 
impounded every serviceable animal in all parts of France. 
At Marshal Canrobert's headquarters we were politely 
interviewed by a senior staff officer. He examined our 
papers and found them en reg/e, and sent them to the Marshal, 
who received us a few minutes later. The Marshal and 
my father (who wore his British captain's uniform) saluted 
each other in the most correct military manner, and the 
Marshal directed his chief-of-staffto assist my father in every 
way. 
At Chalons we then discovered the servant of a Mexican 
attache willing to sell a horse for two thousand francs. 
My father agreed to pay that sum if the servant would 
throw in the saddle and horse equipment. My father was 
thus ready to take the field, but I was still without a 
mount. 
Eventually, however, we found a farmer's wife who had 
a donkey -chaise, in which she used to take fruit, vegetables, 
and eggs to market. Her garden and stores had been 
wrecked by the remount parties quartered on the farm, 
and she had therefore now no occupation. Her husband, 
a weak old man, was unable to work and had left the farm, 
with his married daughter, leaving his wife without food 
or money to shift for herself. 
Suzanne, the farmer's wife, was in great tribulation at 
44 UNDER THE FLAG 
the breaking-up of her home, and feared starvation this 
last a condition shared by many of her neighbours. My 
father suggested that she should sell us her chaise and 
donkey and enter our service. She could look after our 
chaise and traps, and do any job required of her, we 
undertaking to share our food with her, and give her a 
weekly wage of twenty francs. This arrangement met 
with her approval, and she then sold the chaise and the 
donkey to us for five hundred francs, and expressed her 
willingness to start off with us in a couple of hours. 
I remained at the farm, and my father, being now mounted, 
went off, ready to march to the eastward with an advance 
guard of Marshal Canrobert's cuirassiers. My father 
could give me no definite instructions, but told me to move 
in the direct line for Saarbriicken, where the French 
douaniers, on the i9th July, 1870, had fired the first shots 
of the war. 
Suzanne either gave the money she had received from 
me to her husband or had buried it. I was afraid to let 
her out of my sight, so waited until she was ready to start 
for Chalons, where I returned to the quarters we had taken 
at a small hotel. 
After an early breakfast on the 24th July, I paid the 
hotel bill and drew some more cash, in small gold pieces, 
from the agents of my father's bank. I gave Suzanne 
some money to buy oats for the moke and to load the 
chaise with a fortnight's provisions for ourselves, as we 
were unlikely to find any for sale as we advanced to the 
eastward. Her arrangements showed that she was an 
excellent, thoughtful, and economical caterer. 
Since my father had left Paris he had written several 
articles and three news-letters for the Press. He gave me 
these papers with instructions to make two copies of each, 
one of them to be posted to India and the other to London. 
As I had to copy these papers before leaving Chalons, I 
commenced them as soon as possible, partaking of coffee 
and rolls and butter while so employed. The trouble was 
how to get off similar papers in the future. My father said 
if he could not deliver them to me he would get the British 
military attache to include them in his bag for London, 
WAR CLOUDS 45 
addressed to Mrs. Walsh, and she would distribute and 
attend to them. This course eventually he had to adopt. 
On the 28th July I was still in search of my 
father, but could get no information regarding the where- 
abouts of the cuirassier regiment to which he was attached. 
On the 3oth July I heard that a French attack on Saar- 
briicken had failed, and that the French had deemed it 
prudent to retire to their own side of the frontier. The 
evening of the same day I found my father encamped with 
a party of cuirassiers three miles on the French side of 
the frontier. My father was delighted to see me, and we 
related to each other our adventures since we had parted 
at Chalons. He had with him eight articles to be copied 
and sent off to India and to London. These he handed 
to me, and I was fortunate enough to find a stationer, from 
whom I bought paper, pens, and ink. The stationer very 
courteously permitted me to copy my father's papers on his 
premises, which kept me pen-in-hand for eight hours. 
After I had finished my father's articles I saw him for a 
few minutes. "A German invasion of France," he told me, "is 
certain within the next week or ten days. The moment you 
hear of an important French defeat, leave the frontier at 
once. Don't on any account stop to see the fighting. 
Make direct for La Chapelle and then to Laon don't 
return to Chalons. If the French fail to stem the German 
invasion, pay off Suzanne, give her the chaise and donkey, 
and make for England." 
On the 4th August guns and ammunition passed 
me, on their way across the frontier, and others to join 
artillery units on the French side. About 6 p.m. the same 
day I heard that the Crown Prince had defeated Marshal 
Frossard at Wissemburg and Gelsberg, and had actually 
crossed the French boundary. No one believed this 
report. On the 5th August, however, the Frossard defeat 
was confirmed, and also the report that General Douay 
had been killed in action. From what I saw, my father's 
prediction was coming true, and, as I did not desire to be 
overtaken by the Germans, it seemed prudent to leave 
the vicinity of the frontier. 
On the yth August some French infantry halted 
46 UNDER THE FLAG 
near my bivouac, and I at once presented myself to the 
officer in command. I explained who and what I was 
and how I came to be there; and that until I could obtain 
some authentic news as to the movements of the German 
and French Armies I thought it prudent to remain where 
I was. This officer was very polite and kind, and I invited 
him to breakfast with me in my donkey-chaise. At first 
he said that he had not the time, as he had to march without 
delay on Rheims so soon as his men had partaken of their 
morning meal. He consented, however, to view my 
equipage, which was only about 300 yards from where we 
stood talking. 
On our arrival Suzanne welcomed him with la reverence 
due to Monsieur le Colonel, and at once announced that she had 
prepared an "omelette" for him. Alluding, then, to me, 
she expressed her astonishment that my parents allowed 
un petit enfant comme lui courir tout seul\ but, mon Colonel, she 
added, no one interferes with, or restricts the movements of 
ce brave enfant. I was at the time 14! years old, and did not 
consider myself in any way or sense "un enfant". I think 
my six weeks on the French frontier, in daily contact with 
the soldiers of France, both officers and men, widened my 
mind and increased my knowledge of the world ; and in that 
respect I was in advance of an English-brought-up lad of 
my own age. I had told Suzanne that if she was questioned 
about me she was to reply : "He is English. His father 
is an officer of the British Army and a war correspondent 
attached with Marshal Canrobert's consent to the cuiras- 
siers and now at the Front." I wanted mon Colonel to 
know my position, and to derive that information from 
Suzanne. 
We gave mon Colonel a good breakfast and a bottle 
of excellent red wine. He rose to go, and thanked me for 
my hospitality to him, observing that my entrer en compagne 
must have given me many pleasant experiences and an 
insight into the conditions of French military affairs on the 
Haute Marne. As he mounted his horse he said : "If you 
go to Rheims, make inquiries for me." 
I wrote on the jth August, telling my father that 
I was starting to the westward in accordance with his 
WAR CLOUDS 47 
orders, and would hang about as long as I could avoid the 
Germans. But the French postal arrangements had broken 
down, and letters directed to the care of the Chief of 
Staff of the 6th Corps d'Arme'e never reached him. I then 
asked H.M. Embassy to put a letter addressed to my father 
in the bag sent to the British officer attached to the 6th 
Army Corps. That letter, however, only reached him 
after he had severed his connection with the French Army. 
Not knowing what to do in the absence of all communi- 
cation with my father, I went on to Rheims, partly on foot 
and partly in the donkey-chaise with Suzanne. There I 
szwffton Colonel again, and he entertained me very hospitably. 
I left Rheims on the 23rd August, a few hours 
before Marshal MacMahon arrived there to dispatch his 
army to the eastward. Together with Suzanne and the 
donkey-chaise, I took the road for Laon, distant about 
thirty-five miles by road. We travelled by easy stages, 
and arrived there safely without mishap or hindrance of 
any kind. On the 2nd September I discharged 
Suzanne and gave her the donkey and chaise. She was 
delighted with the way in which she had been treated, 
but decided not to return to Chalons until the Germans 
had left that town and district. My adventures were over, 
and I arrived back in London on the jth September, 1870. 
There I heard of Napoleon's surrender, and of the establish- 
ment of a Military Government for the defence of Paris. 
After paying a short visit to recount my adventures 
to my guardian, Colonel Stather, at Woodchester, I returned 
to Cowley College. I was warmly welcomed by the Rev. 
Mr. England, my friend and class-master ; also by the 
Rev. J. G. Watts, the head master and chaplain, and Mr. 
Herman, the principal. They all congratulated me on 
what I had seen and on the way I had taken care of myself. 
My father was not present at the surrender of Napoleon 
at Sedan on the 3rd September, 1870. He had remained 
with the cuirassier regiment, whose fortunes he had 
followed since being attached to that corps at Chalons on 
the 23rd July the same year. The French Armies were 
driven back, and a Republican Government was established 
at Paris on the 4th September, 1870. My father asked 
48 UNDER THE FLAG 
that the permits and papers accrediting him to the Imperial 
Government of France should be recognized by the 
Republican Government and their officers in the field, 
but his request was refused, and he ceased to be a war 
correspondent with the French Army. Having thus been 
forcibly ousted from that post, he crossed over the German 
frontier with his horse and made his way through Luxem- 
bourg and Belgium to England, where he arrived on 
September the izth. 
CHAPTER VII 
BOMBAY 
ON my return from France and my adventurous war-time 
experiences I found it very difficult to settle down to the 
ordinary routine of Cowley College. My class-master, 
Mr. England, continued to take a great interest in my 
studies, and wanted me to gain a "place" in the college 
examinations. This, thanks to his coaching, I succeeded 
in doing. 
I did a great deal of boating from Sandford Lock, and 
frequently went to Abingdon and Newnham Harcourt. 
The rector and owner of the latter property, the Reverend 
William Vernon Harcourt, was always most hospitable 
to all Cowley boys, and we used to leave our boats at 
the "Fisherman's Rest", a small inn at the bend of the 
Thames, and have tea at his residence in Newnham Park. 
I had a Rob Roy canoe, fitted with a centre-board and a 
bilge-piece, and spent a good deal of my time in learning 
to manage and sail my little craft. The practice thus gained 
was of great service to me later on the freshwater canals 
in Egypt. 
Late in September 1871 1 fell into the lock at Sandford, 
and in spite of my wet clothes sailed my Rob Roy canoe 
on to Abingdon. By that folly I caught a terrible chill, 
cold, and cough. The latter settled on my chest, and 
brought on inflammation of the lungs. I spent a full month 
in bed, and the school doctor became anxious about my 
condition. Finally, in consultation with another practi- 
tioner, he decided that I should be sent home and taken to 
the South of Europe. 
On my arrival in London, my father took me to a 
specialist, who advised my leaving England for the winter 
months. My father agreed, but said that he was start- 
ing for Bombay on the iyth November, 1871, and 
49 
50 UNDER THE FLAG 
consequently there was no time to arrange to whose care I 
should be sent. On hearing that, the specialist said : 
"Take the boy to the East with you. The sea voyage to 
India, and the climate of the western coast of India, will 
restore him to health sooner and better than if he went to 
Italy or anywhere in Southern Europe." I was at this 
time 15 years, 8^ months old. 
My father and I arrived in Bombay early in the morning 
of the zist December, 1871. 
After breakfast, my father, wearing a white uniform, 
called to autograph the arrival book at the Brigade Office 
in the Town Hall, Elphinstone Circle. He sent his card 
to the Brigade Major, who greeted him cordially and 
handed him a note from the Governor of Bombay, Sir 
Seymour Fitzgerald. This note directed my father to go 
at once to Government House, Parel. Major Karslake 
said : "The Chief also desires to see you some time to-day. 
As you are encamped within a few yards of the Cooperage, 
call on his military secretary on your return from Parel. 
You could, I think, arrange to get an interview at about 
4 p.m." We then left the Town Hall, and were about to 
step into our hired buggy when a footman announced 
that Sir Albert Sassoon, of Sans Souci, Byculla, had placed 
his carriage at Major Walsh's service. We drove off, 
therefore, in grand style to interview His Excellency the 
Governor. 
On reaching Parel, my father and I both autographed 
the Government House callers' book. An A.D.C. received 
us, and he was told to acquaint Sir Seymour Fitzgerald that 
Major Walsh sought an interview. The A.D.C. returned 
in a few minutes to say that His Excellency would 
receive Major Walsh at once, and we were conducted 
to the library, where Sir Seymour awaited us, seated at 
his desk. 
Sir Seymour got up and greeted my father warmly. 
"I am afraid," he said, "you consider that I treated you 
badly. You were not sent to Abyssinia to command the 
transport train, nor to carry out the scheme which you had 
drawn up, after it had received the approval of the 
Commander-in-Chief, Bombay. But it was not possible 
BOMBAY 51 
to write to you officially, explaining the cause of the unfair 
treatment and ill-usage meted out to you. In the opinion 
of the Commander-in-Chief and myself, however, it is only 
just and fair to tell you the position in which we were 
placed. The Government of India insisted that the 
transport arrangements for Abyssinia should be placed 
under the command of an officer of the Bengal Transport 
Department. The Chief wrote to me on the subject, and 
I sent on his letter asking for a reconsideration of the orders 
of the Bengal military authorities. I urged that to pass you 
over was an injustice ; also that it was against the wishes 
of the Commander-in-Chief of the Bombay Army, who had 
selected you for the duty in question, and had accepted 
the scheme you had drawn up. The Military Department 
of the Government of India, however, would not listen 
to our representations made in your favour. Later you 
took furlough, and started off "on your own" as a volunteer 
to Abyssinia, but the Chief told me that when you turned up 
there he had not any post vacant which he could offer you. 
The Commander-in-Chief asked me to see that you received 
official credit for your scheme, which was successfully 
adopted during the campaign. And this I have done." 
Sir Seymour added : "I also took care that in the official 
history of the war your scheme was quoted in full ; and that 
it was placed in extenso with the official compilations of the 
war in Abyssinia, recorded by the Bombay Military 
Department." 
Sir Seymour then went on to say : "In the foregoing 
circumstances, you ought to receive compensation for 
the loss and hardship inflicted on you. It is therefore a 
pleasure to me to offer you an important and lucrative post 
which you can hold for over three years. A minor native 
prince needs a guardian personally to supervise his 
education, to teach him to ride and shoot, and to impart 
to him the ideas and culture of an English gentleman. 
You are particularly fitted for these duties, and you will 
have a competent staff of European and native teachers to 
assist you. The Prince's State will be under your direct 
administration as the British officer resident at his Court, 
and not in any way under the control of a British political 
5 i UNDER THE FLAG 
agent or a commissioner of a presidential division. The 
monthly salary is fifteen hundred rupees, with residence 
and everything found, as well as a travelling allowance of 
two hundred rupees per mensem." 
My father warmly thanked Sir Seymour for this very 
handsome offer, the acceptance of which he had very 
reluctantly to decline. His Excellency, however, did not 
seem surprised, and said : "You are not personally acquain- 
ted with the present Commander-in-Chief, but he knows 
all about you. He told me that you had specially applied 
to him for regimental service, which he was prepared to 
give you at once ; he also remarked that he wished it was 
in his power to appoint younger men with the up-to-date 
ideas and knowledge you possess to the command of native 
infantry battalions. In his own words, 'Walsh has made 
a study of his profession, as can be seen by his accounts of 
the battles, manoeuvres, and tactics of the 6th and 2nd 
French Army Corps under Marshals Canrobert and 
Frossard/ I have read," Sir Seymour said, "with great 
interest your experiences on the Marne during the campaign 
of 1870." 
My father then explained his position by saying : "I 
am a soldier, sir, and under the present regulations I shall 
render myself ineligible for appointment as commandant 
of a battalion if I have not 'put in' three years' continuous 
regimental service. Thus, with nearly five years of absence 
from a regiment, I cannot, in the ordinary course, join 
any corps. However, since the Commander-in-Chief has 
in my special case abrogated that rule, that difficulty is 
gone. In these circumstances I trust that your Excellency 
will understand the reasons which have compelled me to 
decline your offer of political employment in a department 
in which I should like to serve, and the pay of which post 
would be very acceptable after three years on half-pay. 
My ambition and desire is to get command of a regiment, 
qualify for a brigade, and finish up as a general of division 
on the Bombay Military Establishment. And to make 
that career possible of attainment, it is essential for me to 
join a regiment at once." 
Sir Seymour observed : "With those views and aims 
BOMBAY 53 
you have adopted the right course, and I understand that, 
after having served for one year with a battalion, you would 
be glad to get a civil appointment. Unfortunately, my 
term as Governor of this Presidency ceases in May next, 
so I shall not be here to help you obtain a well-paid position 
under the Civil Government. I will leave on record my 
appreciation of your services and claims, and will personally 
and officially urge my successor to recognize and reward 
them. I had hoped to get another Governorship, but the 
Prime Minister has requested me to obtain a seat in the 
House of Commons as soon as possible, and I have already 
asked my former constituents at Horsham to return me as 
the Member for that Borough." 
During the interview between Sir Seymour and my 
father I sat as an attentive listener. At the end, Sir Seymour, 
turning towards me, said to my father : "Your boy, Walsh, 
eh ? I suppose you want his appointment to the Bombay 
District Police ; a very good Service, and as in future it is 
not to be officered by men of the Indian Army, it offers 
a splendid career for a youngster who can shoot, ride, and 
hold a hog-spear. The Forest Department is also an 
excellent Service, but it appears to me that the India Office 
intends to pass over locally appointed men in favour of 
candidates trained at the various Forest schools in France 
and Germany." 
My father thanked Sir Seymour, and explained 
that he was sending me back to England now that I 
had recovered my health, to have me "coached" for the 
Army Competitive Examination, which new scheme had 
lately been introduced. Whereupon Sir Seymour, speak- 
ing to me, said : "Your father is taking the best course for 
your career in life. My experience is that if a man takes 
any office under the Government of India, he should belong 
to one of the covenanted Services. Your age would 
render it difficult for me to appoint you to one of the local 
uncovenanted Services, so I wish you success at the 
examination." 
My father told Sir Seymour that on second thoughts 
he thought it would be prudent to have my name down for 
the Police. Sir Seymour replied : "It will be quite useless 
54 UNDER THE FLAG 
to do so, as the new Governor will tear up his predecessor's 
list of candidates. But I can do better than that. If 
your son applies for appointment to the Police, and urges 
the claims of his family for employment in this Presidency, 
I will, on public grounds, recognize them and appoint him 
substantively to the second or third Police vacancy which 
occurs." Sir Seymour then sent for his son, who was also 
his private secretary, and directed him to write to me 
officially in the above sense. I hoped that, with this pros- 
pect in view, my father would not send me back to school 
in England ; and Doctor Rogers, the Presidency surgeon, 
recommended that I should remain in India for at least 
another six months before being exposed to the winter 
rigours of the climate in England. 
Sir Seymour asked us to stay to lunch, observing that 
if my father went direct from Parel to the Cooperage he 
would catch the Commander-in-Chief before the latter had 
closed his office. We left Government House, therefore, 
shortly after lunch, and my father dropped me at our tents 
before going on to his interview with the Commander-in- 
Chief. On inquiring from the Military Secretary, my 
father was told that the Commander-in-Chief would see 
him at once. 
My father explained to the Chief his reasons for seeking 
immediate regimental employment. His Excellency replied : 
"You are on twenty-one days 'joining time leave'. If you 
cancel that leave, I will attach you at once to the i9th 
Native Infantry now in Bombay. I may tell you con- 
fidentially that the Commandant goes on furlough shortly, 
for six months at least, with, I think, the intention of 
extending it, as he could do, up to two years. In that 
case, if you are de facto attached to the i9th N.L, you would 
as a matter of seniority succeed to the command, and retain 
that position until someone senior to you was appointed 
by me to that temporary vacancy. Moreover, as he has 
only applied for short leave, I am not likely to disturb 
you." 
This arrangement suited my father's plans and require- 
ments, and he announced them to us when we were having 
tea in the canaught of the tent. There my uncle, Captain 
BOMBAY 55 
W. P. Walshe, was also seated, and on seeing me he said : 
"Put on your flannels and bring your cricket bag." The 
latter contained a couple of good bats, a pair of pads, and 
indiarubber finger-protected gloves. I was then taken 
to the Bombay Gymkhana located in one large tent and 
several smaller ones, pitched on the Maidan and close 
to the statue of Her Most Gracious Majesty Queen 
Victoria. 
My uncle got me made a member of the Bombay 
Gymkhana. In those days (1871) the permanent club 
house which now exists had not been built. I was intro- 
duced to several members, and W. A. Baker, manager of 
the National Bank of India, went to the net for a spell. 
He was not wearing gloves or pads, and before bowling 
I called out to him : "Round arm, fast." Now the unfor- 
tunate feature of my bowling was that, though very swift 
and well pitched for length, it was frequently wide to the 
offside of the wicket. I sent up several ill-directed balls 
with that defect, and I suppose that they must have annoyed 
Baker. At any rate, he shouted out to me : "Throw your 
balls at the wicket 1" My next two balls were dead on the 
wicket, but passed just above the bails and were very 
difficult to play. The third ball was very fast and broke 
Baker's thumb. I was in no way to blame for this mishap, 
and expressed my sincere sorrow at his misfortune. 
Curiously enough, we became and remained great friends 
until his death many years after in London, where he was 
managing director of the National Bank of India in Bishops- 
gate Street. 
I played cricket regularly, and soon got acquainted with 
the members of the Gymkhana. Although my form did 
not warrant my inclusion in any of the elevens, yet, as 
many men could not get away from their offices to attend 
matches played up-country, or could not afford the expense 
of day or week-end trips by rail for that purpose, I frequently 
played for the Gymkhana at Almedabad, Colaba, Surat, 
Poona, Kirkee, and other Mofusil towns. This was a very 
enjoyable way of seeing the country. And as I was gener- 
ally "put up" wherever I stopped, I met many pleasant 
people, with whom I often got a few days' shooting, and 
5 6 UNDER THE FLAG 
occasionally a "mount" to pursue with spear the "mighty 
boar". 
My father, on learning that he would be attached to the 
1 9th Native Infantry in Bombay, purchased an Arab horse 
which had never been trained. He had already a lovely 
docile animal for Mrs. Walsh, and a pair of "crocks" for 
the landau, which he had brought out from England. 
He had therefore to procure a charger capable of carrying 
seventeen stone, which was his total riding weight with 
"all up". An Arab, or Cape horse, up to that weight is 
very rare and expensive, and such an animal was not then 
on the Bombay market. He was thus compelled to 
purchase a "waler", which stood over seventeen hands 
nigh and was a wicked, vicious beast. 
The first trouble was to get on the back of this wild 
Australian brute, and then to be able to remain there. 
This waler objected to any rider, and tried to get rid of his 
burden by plunging in the air, doubling his back like a 
cat and simultaneously kicking like a donkey. I endeav- 
oured to "stick on" during these antics, but, much to my 
chagrin, was easily flung off. The Australian rough- 
rider, generally called a larrikin, who had come to Bombay 
with a batch of unbroken horses, told me that this 
particular horse had thrown him out of the saddle on several 
occasions. At last, however, the rough-rider had devised 
a means of sitting this beast, despite all efforts to dismount 
him. On my eagerly asking to be shown this device, he 
proceeded to place a rope under the horse's belly, with a 
loop close to the crupper end of the saddle, and another 
rope to the withers inside the forelegs, with a loop adjoin- 
ing the pommel of the saddle. He then manoeuvred the 
horse under the bough of a tree, dropped from it into the 
saddle, and with each hand seized one of the loops. He 
had a flexible cane attached to his wrist, and wore a pair 
of sharp heavy spurs. The horse kicked, plunged, danced 
on two legs, curled his back, breaking the girths of the 
saddle, but could not get rid of his rider, who flogged and 
spurred him unmercifully, until the brute became tame and 
docile by exhaustion. 
My father observed that, with proper handling and 
BOMBAY 57 
training, he felt certain this waler could become a suitable 
charger for a man of his weight. The question was, who 
was to "break in" this redoubtable quadruped ? The 
seller asked Rs. 700, and to make delivery on the spot; 
but my father tendered Rs. 600, with delivery at his camp 
in the Strangers Lines Fort, and all the horse's gear and 
fittings, including the set of ropes with which the animal 
had been controlled. The offer was accepted, and the 
arrival of this waler with such an evil reputation caused 
Mrs. Walsh considerable anxiety. She did all she could 
to persuade her husband not to mount the horse until it 
had been cured of its vices and thoroughly trained. 
My father ordered the horse to be saddled and taken the 
next morning on to the firm sand in Back Bay, opposite the 
Cooperage. It struck me that I might, unknown to any- 
one, render the waler manageable before my father got 
on the brute's back. Shortly before five o'clock, therefore, 
I had the waler saddled and equipped under my personal 
supervision, in the same way in which the animal had last 
been ridden by the larrikin. The beast was then conducted 
over the railway metals into Back Bay, where after con- 
siderable exertion I managed to scramble into the saddle. 
I fully expected the waler to plunge, kick, walk on his 
hind legs and do his best to throw me off; instead, he 
simply ran away with me. Such behaviour did not disturb 
me, as the beach was clear for about four miles and the 
going as level as a billiard table. I allowed him to "keep 
his head", and did not attempt to check his speed until we 
got nearly to the foot of Malabar Hill. There I guided 
my "runaway" to the left, so as to get all the available 
width for turning round. This induced the animal 
voluntarily to slacken his pace, but made him exhibit 
several pranks in his efforts to get rid of his rider. I 
met those tactics by application of the whip and spur, and 
forced the animal at his top speed back towards the 
Cooperage. It appeared to me that there was still a lot 
of the spice of the devil left in this "waler from under the 
Southern Cross", and so, much against his inclination, I 
raced him back as far as the burning-ground for dead 
Hindoos. He had thus travelled at a great pace for over 
5 8 UNDER THE FLAG 
eight miles, and now showed exhaustion and docility. 
For this I was truly grateful, as I myself was nearly dead 
with fatigue. 
My subdued steed carried me to our encampment, 
and there I handed him over to my father's rough-rider, 
Charbuk Sowar (literally 'a horseman with a whip'), who put 
on a couple of syces to rub the horse down and remove 
all traces of that morning's exercise. At 9 a.m. the waler 
was brought to the entrance of the sleeping -tent, where my 
father had great difficulty in overcoming the horse's objec- 
tion to let him mount. After a sharp struggle, however, 
he got into the saddle, and found the animal had become 
fairly amenable to a heavily curbed bridle, spurs, and 
hunting-crop. Without doubt my father's great weight 
largely contributed towards his steed's comparatively quiet 
behaviour. 
This waler's manners and temper were never very 
dependable, and he constantly gave trouble for no apparent 
reason. Nevertheless, by careful methods and judgment 
my father rode this horse on parade for several years 
without any serious mishaps. When the Prince of Wales 
visited India in 1875, six field officers formed a guard of 
honour around the royal carriage. During the procession 
through the city of Bombay my father, being posted on 
the left-hand door, passed in full view of the Bombay Club 
on his well-known waler, and received a great ovation from 
the members seated on the veranda. A few years later 
this waler died, and Mr. Schenk, an American citizen, 
manager of the horse-drawn cars of the Bombay Tramway 
Co., had the animal stuffed and set up in the hall of the 
head tramway building on Colaba Causeway, where for 
many years it stood labelled as the charger ridden in the 
Royal Procession by Major T. Prendergast Walsh of the 
Bombay 1 9th Infantry. 
On one occasion the waler by his behaviour stood me 
in very good stead. Early one morning, in response to 
an invitation, I rode the animal to No. 141, Mabar Hill, the 
residence of the Honourable Mr. Justice L. Holyoak 
Bayley, a prime judge of the Bombay High Court. I 
found Mr. Bayley on the veranda of his bungalow, and 
BOMBAY 59 
he asked me to come in and have some chota ha^ari. 
My steed would not approach the house, but plunged, 
kicked, and nearly caused me to ride over a gentleman 
seated in the drive sketching before an easel. I eventually 
managed to get off the horse's back, and made him fast with 
my steel rein to a tree. The man sketching turned out to 
be Sir Richard Temple, and on my being introduced to him 
he remarked that Mr. Bayley had told him of my desire for 
a Police appointment on the Frontier. Sir Richard then 
went on to say that, after seeing me manage an unruly 
horse, he could testify to my skill in equitation, and would 
also place on record that in his opinion I was specially 
fitted for employment on the Frontier in the Police Service 
of the Government of India. This was my first meeting 
with Sir Richard Temple, who later was my patron, and who 
elected me for the Indian Political Service. 
Sir Richard and Lady Temple were going by sea to 
Calcutta, and had arranged to land at Marma Goa to visit 
Old Goa. I also happened to be travelling as far as Ven- 
guria by the same coasting vessel. During this voyage I 
became more closely acquainted with Sir Richard, and I 
owed everything to this piece of good fortune. Some years 
later Sir Richard was appointed Governor of Bombay. 
In that position he became aware that I had for some years 
been a regular contributor to the local Press, and had 
frequently furnished the political authorities with useful 
information regarding the affairs and intrigues on both 
shores of the Red Sea littoral. This fact enabled Sir 
Richard to post me as an assistant political agent in Kathiawar. 
When doing so, however, he was mindful to remark that 
the Secretary of State would probably remove me from that 
office, as many of the competitive covenanted Civil Servants 
objected to the employment of an "outsider" in the ex- 
clusive preserve of the Indian Political Service. Sir 
Richard, nevertheless, wished me well, and said : "I shall 
have left India before you can be turned out, but if you are 
ejected, write to me and I will personally explain your 
claims to the Secretary of State. Your case will also be 
strongly supported by Sir Henry Rawlinson (formerly of 
your father's old regiment), and now a member of the 
60 UNDER THE FLAG 
India Office Council. We will fight the matter out 
moreover, as I intend to enter Parliament, I shall be in a 
position to invite attention in the House of Commons to 
the absurdities of this ancient regulation, which restricts 
and curtails the freedom of the Government to select 
candidates for several offices under the Local and the 
Government of India." 
My father joined the i9th Native Infantry, and, having 
no appointment in the regiment, had practically nothing 
to do except garrison duties. On all possible occasions I 
accompanied my father to the places he had to visit, so 
I soon knew a good deal about the Land Defence and 
topography of the islands of Bombay. 
I was greatly amused by my father's method of bringing 
his knowledge of battalion drill up to date. He took several 
pairs of privates and gave the ends of a rope to be held by 
each of the two, by this means turning a pair into a com- 
pany. The Adjutant, Captain Wandby, said to my father : 
"Well, sir, you know more about battalion drill than any 
officer in the regiment, and I have grouped in your records 
the officially expressed opinion by several senior officers on 
that subject." My father replied : "That may be quite 
correct, but I want that fact to be known to my present 
officer commanding. I, of course, attend all the C.O.'s 
parades, but am practically a mere spectator. I want the 
C.O. to call me out to execute any manoeuvre he may direct 
me to do, and, if it is done to his satisfaction, to acquaint 
the Commander-in-Chief of my fitness to command a 
battalion." Colonel G. W. Price, Commandant of the 
1 9th Regiment, readily complied with both of my father's 
requests. In the meantime I had been handed over to 
Captain Wandby, to be taught company drill and to 
practise musketry. Although I possessed a certificate of 
fitness from the Cowley College Cadet Corps, a little extra 
drill in the ranks with sepoys did me no harm, and I thereby 
got to know the native soldier. 
As my father was only drawing the bare pay of his 
rank, he declared that he must devote as much of his time 
as possible to writing for the Press. He estimated that the 
remuneration thereby gained would recoup him to a 
BOMBAY 61 
great extent for his loss of staff or civil employment pay. 
He possessed a brass-bound box containing what he called 
his "portable library", which consisted of the following 
books : Webster's English Dictionary ; The Dictionary Appen- 
dix, by the Rev. Thesaurus ; Manders' Treasury of Knowledge ; 
Cruden's Concordance of the Bible ; Haydn's Dictionary of Dates ; 
a law lexicon ; Whitaker's Almanack ; The Queen's (Army) 
Regulations ; The British Army 'List Official ; an Indian Army 
List ; a Hindustani dictionary (Forbes'). Most of these he 
left to me, and are regarded by me as treasures. His 
library box was always left open on two chairs at the right- 
hand side of his writing-table, and he placed with it any 
book which he might have to review. Pen, ink, papers, 
rubber, and ink-eraser completed the box's equipment. 
My father was preparing an article for a home newspaper, 
when Mr. M. Maclean, proprietor and editor of the Bombay 
Gazette, drove up in a shigram (generally called a "Brandy- 
case on wheels") to the tent. Mr. Maclean said that 
H.E. the Governor had asked him to write a series of articles 
on the Slave Trade Treaty or Agreement with Zanzibar, 
which Sir Bartle Frere was endeavouring to negotiate with 
the Sultan of Zanzibar. My father asked Maclean if the 
Treaty had been actually ratified, or if its provisions were 
still in draft and under discussion. Maclean had no 
definite information on those points, but said that His 
Excellency would let him see, in confidence, some particulars 
which had come to his hand. Maclean added that there 
was a rumour that Sir Seymour Fitzgerald had appointed 
his son (afterwards Sir W. G. S. Vesey Fitzgerald, K.C.I.E., 
C.S.I., Political A.D.C. to the Secretary of State for India) 
to a new post in the Persian Gulf, to control the operation 
of the Slave Trade Treaty with Zanzibar and Muscat ; the 
Secretary of State, however, had declined to sanction the 
creation of such an office. 
My father replied to Maclean : "I could not write the 
articles you require, as I know nothing about Zanzibar, 
Muscat, and the slave trade. There are about 7,000 
natives of India trading with Zanzibar, but it is commonly 
supposed that the Zanzibar slave trade is financed by 
native merchants from the Gujarat, Kathiawar, and Kutch 
62 UNDER THE FLAG 
ports. I am personally acquainted with the heads of 
several large native firms who have agencies in Zanzibar ; 
and almost certainly the immense business carried on by 
them at the latter place does indirectly subsidize the dealers 
in slaves, who buy goods in Zanzibar and exchange them 
for slaves, which is often a cheaper and more effective 
method than capturing them by force of arms. No doubt 
if the slave trade (which includes the purchase and con- 
veyance of ivory to the coast) was stopped entirely, 
Gujarat merchants would lose the best market for the sale 
of their goods. There is a party at Zanzibar, chiefly Arabs, 
desirous of emancipating all slaves, in order to annoy the 
Sultan, whose slaves pick and collect the crops from the 
large pepper plantations owned by His Highness at Penn- 
baam and elsewhere. If slave labour could not be used 
for that purpose, the Sultan would be compelled to pay 
for coolies, or to give contracts for the collection of pepper. 
It is considered that if either course were adopted the 
farmers would make large profits and the Sultan would 
receive little or no revenue. This Zanzibar question, 
therefore, has many aspects and needs to be carefully 
studied." 
My father continued to the effect that, if he went into 
the matter, he could only do so by approaching the impor- 
tant merchants whom he knew, which would attract 
attention. He offered, however, to introduce me to the 
merchants in the ordinary way, and he could then easily 
pick up or extract their views on the subject. "I will 
send my son to see Shahabuddin and to investigate Sir 
Bartle Frere's proposals, and thus open communications 
with the secretary to Sir Bartle Frere's mission, who could 
easily supply full particulars." Mr. Maclean replied that 
he would talk the matter over with Faichnie, assistant 
editor of the Gazette, and then get him to discuss it with 
myself. Eventually, with the adoption of this course, I 
was invited to study and to write articles on the burning 
question of the day : the traffic in slaves on the East Coast 
of Africa, and the extent to which the merchants of western 
India were implicated. For several years I contributed to 
the Bombay Gazette and The Times of India, continuing to 
BOMBAY 63 
do so right up till my appointment in 1 884 as Administrator 
at Berbera, Somaliland, which brought me officially into 
contact with the slave trade between the Gulf of Tajura 
and Turkish Arabia. 
I had to go over to the Gazette office three or four times 
a week to read the proofs of my father's articles, and often 
did not complete that work until two or three o'clock in 
the morning. As I generally had to wait idly until the 
articles were set up in type, I frequently filled in the spare 
time by helping Faichnie to read the proofs of contributions 
from the pen of Mrs. Kipling (the mother of Rudyard 
Kipling, and the wife of a drawing master at the School 
of Art) on Bombay society gossip ; also those of 
Colonel C. M. MacGregor, B.Sc. (whose sister Annie I 
married in 1891), on the defence of the Indian Frontier 
and the aims and advance of Russia in Central Asia. Both 
Mr. Martin Wood (editor of The Times of India} and Mr. 
Maclean used to employ me to write short paragraphs on 
the theatrical performances, concerts, public dinners, and 
entertainments occurring in Bombay. This was a most 
useful occupation, and incidentally kept me supplied with 
pocket money. It also introduced me at the early age of 
sixteen to the editors Wood, Maclean, Robert Knight (of 
the Statesman)^ and staff of the Press in the Bombay Presi- 
dency. After entering the Marine Postal Service between 
Bombay and Suez in 1873, I kept up my connection 
with all the newspapers published in Bombay, and 
contributed to them regularly on the following subjects : 
"The slave trade" ; 'The hardships borne by, and the 
injustice done to, the natives of British India making the 
pilgrimage to Mecca" ; "Treatment of British ships by the 
Suez Canal Company" ; "Egyptian quarantine regulations 
used to delay passage of British mails by rail through 
Egypt" ; "The dual control on the land of Pharaoh" ; 
"The Khedival debts" ; "The war between Egypt and 
Abyssinia" ; "The freshwater irrigational canals of the 
Delta fed by the Nile, and the small coast-traffic towed 
through some of those channels" ; "The efforts of Euro- 
pean Powers to get a footing on the shores of the Red 
Sea, and on those of the Gulf of Aden" ; "Political affairs 
64 UNDER THE FLAG 
and intrigues on both littorals of the Red Sea" ; "Gordon 
in the Sudan" ; "Captain Richard Burton's mission to 
look for gold in Midian". 
My father, my uncle (Mr. W. P. Walsh), Maclean, and 
Grattan Geary (the editor of The Times of India) encouraged 
my "ink-slinging" inclinations ; and, looking back over 
a period of more than fifty years, I see clearly that such 
success as I have had during my humble career in the East 
was entirely due to my connection with the Press of 
western India, and to the high officials and others whose 
acquaintance I made in connection with my pen. 
CHAPTER VIII 
THE MUTINY INDIAN CIVIL SERVANTS 
I WOULD remind my readers that the Mutiny broke out at 
Meerut on the loth May, 1857, and as far as the native soldiers, 
as organized mutineers, were concerned, it was suppressed 
in the same year, or early in 1858. The troops and in- 
habitants of a few native states, notably Oude, were in 
rebellion against the British rule up to 1859, the date of 
the capture and execution of Tantia Topee. The Nana 
Sahib of Bithoor, the chief instigator of the Mutiny, and 
the murderer of our women and children at Cawnpore, 
successfully escaped capture, and was officially reported 
to have died in the Terai jungle, where he had taken refuge. 
The death of this notorious and treacherous scoundrel 
was not believed, and certainly natives deemed him to be 
living in disguise. In 1872 several fanatics in various parts 
of India, claiming to be the Nana Sahib, gave themselves 
up to the police, while another of them was arrested in 
Bombay, but at the inquiry it was proved definitely that 
he was not the infamous outlaw. 
I arrived in India, say, twelve years after India had been 
transferred to the Crown in 1858; consequently the 
majority of the officers of the Indian armies of that date had 
served in India during the Mutiny campaigns. Competi- 
tion for entrance into the covenanted Civil Service was 
introduced in November 1858; the latter recruits were 
styled "competition wallahs", and by reason of their being 
still juniors had not risen in 1872 to power and position 
in the covenanted Civil Service of India. The members 
of this service, who governed the country, had all come from 
Haileybury, and they looked down upon the newcomers 
as their social inferiors. As regards the first three batches 
of "competition wallahs", I saw no distinction between 
the new and the old Civil Servants in class or caste. Later 
65 v 
66 UNDER THE FLAG 
on, however, the difference was very obvious ; not only 
in their status, manners, and bearing, but also in their ideas. 
The "competition wallah" was simply and entirely a 
"trade unionist" attempting to dictate the policy of 
Government, and considered himself to be in all respects 
vastly superior to all military and uncovenanted servants 
of the Crown. 
A group of "competition wallahs" publicly attacked 
Sir Bartle Frere (who had himself been an Indian Civil 
Servant of the Haileybury brand) for the way in which he 
exercised his patronage. They claimed that under an 
Act of Parliament a Governor's power of selection of a 
candidate for certain important offices was restricted to his 
choosing a member of the covenanted Civil Service to 
fill them. Sir Bartle resented such dictation from Civil 
Servants under his jurisdiction or command, and dealt with 
the matter in an able and well-reasoned despatch, dated 
December 1864, to the Secretary of State for India. 
Nevertheless, claims of this nature were constantly cropping 
up, and with a weak-kneed or "civilian-ridden" governor 
caused serious trouble and embarrassment to the Govern- 
ment of the Presidency. 
When Sir Richard Temple became Governor of Bom- 
bay he appointed a Mr. G. H. R. Hart, an uncovenanted 
officer, to be his private secretary, so as not to have in his 
personal cabinet one of the Secretariat group of "trade 
unionists". This action was the first terrible blow Sir 
Richard levelled at the "competition wallah" combination. 
The latter became alarmed and organized an opposition 
to Sir Richard's policy ; especially since he had appointed 
me an Assistant Political Agent in Kathiawar. For this post 
they asserted that under the Regulations no uncovenanted 
officer was eligible, and they tried to prevent my joining 
it. But Sir Richard stood firm, and would not brook any 
dictation or interference with his patronage. I had there- 
fore to face and fight these opponents to my employment, 
and I was loyally supported by Sir Richard Temple, as well 
as Mr. E. W. Ravenscroft, C.S.I. (an old Haileybury Civil 
Servant in Bombay), and by Sir Henry Rawlinson, a member 
of the India Office Council in London. 
THE MUTINY INDIAN CIVIL SERVANTS 67 
Although the "competition wallahs" pressed by all 
means in their power not to allow my appointment to the 
Political Service, yet many of them personally wished me 
well, and made several efforts to effect a settlement of my 
claims. With that object in view, I was offered a Presidency 
Magistracy, the Clerkship of the Court of Small Causes, 
Assistant-Commissionership in the Salt Department, and an 
Assistant-Superintendentship of Police, in a district where 
the Superintendent^was about to^take two years' furlough, 
which arrangement would at once make me an : Acting 
Superintendent. In point of mere pay, the emoluments of 
these offices were equal to, and in some instances exceeded, 
my pay as a political officer. Sir Richard Temple had 
appointed two other uncovenanted men to the Political 
Service, but the Secretariat got rid of both of them, these 
gentlemen taking offices in other Departments. I myself 
could easily have secured similar preferment and treatment, 
but on my father's advice I demanded reinstatement in the 
Political Service as my first and only compensation, and 
said that after my name had been published as a political 
officer in the Bombay Government Gazette I would con- 
sider any offer of transfer made to me. If, however, the 
Local Government did not reappoint me to the Political 
Department, I desired to place on record my intention of 
appeal to the Secretary of State, and if I failed to obtain 
redress at the hands of the latter, I purposed placing my 
case before Parliament, and even to lay it at the foot of Her 
Most Gracious Majesty Queen Victoria's Throne. 
I could afford to hold out, as when ousted from the 
Political Department I reverted automatically to the Marine 
Postal Service, upon which Department I had been mindful 
to retain a lien. Mr. H. E. M. James (afterwards Sir 
Evan James, K.C.I.E.) had tried to keep me in the Postal 
Service, and proposed to count my "sea time" for seniority 
as a Superintendent of Post Offices, and then to give me the 
first acting or permanent vacancy as Deputy Postmaster- 
General. In point of pay and pecuniary prospects, the 
acceptance of this kind offer would have benefited me to 
a much greater extent than re-employment in the Political 
Service, or in any Department ; since in all of them, 
68 UNDER THE FLAG 
salaries, in the early stages, were small and promotion very 
slow. I declined, however, any kind of advancement in 
the Indian Postal Department, whereupon Mr. James 
asked me why I did so. My reply was very simple, but it 
opened his eyes. I explained : "Suppose I became a 
postal official, it would probably be impossible, and certainly 
it would be difficult, to get elected to a club in Bombay, 
or even to one in an up-country station. Even pure-white 
European postal servants nearly all belong to the order of 
    

